Barbara Jordan's 1977 Harvard Commencement Address: The People Demand a Role

Were I to begin by saying I was pleased to have been invited to speak to the Harvard community on this occasion, you might consider it nothing more than a trite beginning. You would be in error. I have always held Harvard in high regard and viewed a Harvard education as the unexcelled badge of intellectual achievement, if not superiority. My appearance here may not honor you, but it certainly honors me. One reason I attended Boston University Law School was so that I could be close.

My earliest brush with Harvard occurred years ago when I was a junior at Texas Southern University. I might add that TSU, originally named Texas State University for Negroes, was created in order to keep Blacks out of the University of Texas. The Harvard debate team came to TSU. I was a debater. I didn't understand why representatives of this school, so revered by me, would come to debate TSU. My perplexity notwithstanding, the debate occurred. The judge's decision was that the debate ended in a tie.

It occurs to me that if Harvard students were as superior as everyone thought, they should have won. Since the score was tied, we must have won.

So, before beginning my speech, I hereby declare that in a debate between Texas Southern University and Harvard University, Texas Southern won. If you have any surplus trophies around, I will take one home to the team.

The invitation to be here today appeared designed either to challenge or intimidate. I quote an unedited paragraph from the letter of invitation: “We invite you to speak on whatever topic you find suitable. A number of Harvard commencement speeches have been memorable. Perhaps the most memorable was that of Secretary of State George C. Marshall, who used the occasion to announce the Marshall Plan for Europe.”

A Jordan plan to create, ameliorate, or eliminate will not be announced at this time. If I think of one at any time during the remainder of my life, I will request a return visit.

Even though I will not present a plan which will be celebrated thirty years hence, I will talk to you about a problem which concerns me greatly. The answers are not in the back of the book—nor at the end of the speech.

Of late, many articles have been written and speeches delivered about the importance of the input of the people into the affairs of the government. Symbolic gestures have been staged and populist rhetoric has been translated into law. The point of it all is to make people feel that they really do count and that the government does care what they think. Such actions are said to be the logical extension and proper fulfillment of an amorphous something called the promise of America.

Do the governors of America sincerely believe that people are a valuable resource of the government, or do the governors believe the people are an indispensable nuisance to a democracy?

Let us reflect on our history for a moment. The Declaration of Independence, a relatively short document, is rife with references to people.

In the very first sentence of the Declaration: “When ... it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands....” Whenever a government becomes destructive of certain unalienable rights, “it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it.”

In itemizing the oppressiveness of George III: “He has refused to pass other laws for the accommodation of large districts of people, unless those people would relinquish the right of representation in the legislature”; “his invasions on the rights of the people”; “he has sent hither swarms of officers to harass our people”; “he has destroyed the lives of our people.” And finally, the Declaration is made in the name and by authority of the good people.

Subsequently, the Constitution augmented and implemented the political philosophy espoused in the Declaration of Independence. The raison d'être of the new government—the political well-being of the people—and the government's source of authority—the people—were once more and again quintessential.

“We the People of the United States.” “The House of Representatives ... chosen every second year by the people.” “The right of the people peaceably to assemble.” “The right of the people to be secure in their persons.” Enumeration of certain rights retained by the people. Certain powers reserved to the people.

As the states proceeded to ratify the Constitution, the role of the people vis-à-vis the Congress remained at issue. During the New York State constitutional convention, a resolution was proposed to strip from the Congress the power to lay and collect taxes. Alexander Hamilton sought to allay the delegates' fear that Congress would usurp the power of the people. Hamilton said, addressing the proponent of the resolution, “Here, sir, the people govern....”

Here, sir, the people govern.

Do the people govern, or has there been a mutation from a commitment to people to a commitment to self-interest on the part of the governors? Is the applause meter paramount and the general welfare of the people at best merely tangential?

The government has built an elaborate network of illusions designed to make people believe that their opinions are genuinely wanted and considered; that they participate, in fact, in making the decisions of government. We go to great lengths to sustain the illusion. Prevalent phrases in recent legislation are “citizen participation,” “advisory council,” “advisory committee,” “maximum feasible participation,” “public participation,” “community participation,” and “petition for intervention.”

The words are there. But is citizen intervention encouraged or discouraged?

Petitions to intervene in regulatory agency proceedings present a premier example of how best to discourage citizen participation. The rules for intervention in a proceeding of the Atomic Energy Commission are typical.

2.714 Intervention (in adjudicatory proceedings): “Any person whose interest may be affected by a proceeding and who desires to participate as a party shall file in a written petition ... for leave to intervene. Any petition shall identify the specific aspect or aspects of the subject matter of the proceedings as to which he wishes to intervene and set forth with particularity both the facts pertaining to his interest and the basis for his contentions with regard to each aspect on which he desires to intervene.”

The regulations then continue for seventeen additional sections and subsections. Citizen intervention in the proceedings of other regulatory agencies is equally burdensome.

The people have a right to intervene. Though statutory and regulatory language may well include provisions for petitions to intervene, the fact is that proper citizen participation often requires the assistance of an attorney and/or expert witnesses to assist in presenting complicated subject matter. If the citizen needs such assistance and cannot afford an attorney or expert witness, he is effectively denied the right to intervene. The Supreme Court has held that only Congress may authorize the payment of such fees. Congress appears reluctant to do that.

Have Supreme Court decisions furthered opportunities for citizen participation? Recently the Court has acted to limit both the right to sue and class-action litigation. The Court ruled that citizens and taxpayers have no standing to challenge an action of the government unless they can show a concrete “injury in fact.”

The Court ruled that ghetto residents in Rochester lacked standing to challenge an alleged pattern of exclusionary zoning because they could not prove that the alleged practice actually harmed them personally. The Court ruled that plaintiffs must demonstrate that the injury about which they complained was actual as opposed to arguable.

There is a federal requirement that the amount in controversy must be at least $10,000 before federal court consideration can occur. The Supreme Court has ruled that even if plaintiffs individually satisfied the jurisdictional amount, no class action would be allowed unless each member of the class satisfied the jurisdictional amount. The Court has ruled that a person bringing a class action must notify all persons in the class at his own expense.

The people want in. How much longer will they tolerate the network of illusions and vacuous rhetoric? What the people want is simple: an America as good as its promise.

We want to be in control of our lives—whether we are jungle fighters, craftsmen, company men, or gamesmen—we want to be in control, and when government erodes that control, we are discomfited.

I submit that the re-inclusion of the people in their government would be a recombinant with predictable and laudable results. It would be the return of a right that was once considered unalienable.

The stakes are too high for government to be a spectator sport.

署名Barbara Jordan  1977-06-16  published in Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts