David Naylor's 2019 Honorary Degree Address at University of Toronto: The Future of Health Care

Special greetings to Chancellor Rose Patten, President Meric Gertler and Dean Trevor Young. Mr. President, thank you for those kind words, and Madam Chancellor, thank you for this honour. I am deeply grateful to the University of Toronto for inviting me to graduate with these outstanding students receiving degrees or diplomas from the Faculty of Medicine. This is yet another debt I owe this extraordinary institution.

I am humbled to share the platform with so many distinguished friends and colleagues. To the graduating classes—those who, unlike me, truly earned their degrees or diplomas—what a privilege it is to join you and your families, friends, fans and supporters on this special day.

Some of today's graduates are veterans of previous convocations. So am I: about 150 of them as dean of medicine and president. But before today, the only time I came onto this stage to receive a degree was forty-one years ago. I confess that I remember no one on stage except the associate dean who hooded us, and nothing any speaker said. So, given that I am a forgettable and fake graduate, these remarks will be brief.

Let us state the obvious. This is a troubled time in our species' history: polarized politics, degraded civil discourse, concentrated wealth and accelerating climate change. Especially relevant to today's graduates is a rising tide of fallacies about health and illness, evident as many countries experience alarming returns of measles and other preventable communicable diseases.

Some of you will meet curmudgeons from my generation who tell you how wonderful medicine and health care were in the good old days. Do not believe a word of it. You are entering health care during accelerating change that will be both challenging and revolutionary in the best sense.

Turn the clock back to 1978, when I graduated. The first cell phone did not appear until 1979. Personal computers gained a serious following only in the mid-1980s; there was essentially no internet and certainly no World Wide Web. Gene splicing had been invented in 1973, but sequencing an entire genome was almost inconceivable.

CT scanning had arrived, but magnetic-resonance imaging was in its infancy and image interpretation was primitive by today's standards. Stem cells' potential was only dimly understood. Most drugs came from painstaking medicinal chemistry, with few biological agents. When President Richard Nixon funded a great war on cancer in the 1970s, science simply was not ready and the results were crushingly disappointing.

Even a dozen years ago, I used to describe the four P's of modern health care as poking, prodding, plumbing and palliation—not very appealing. By 2015, however, British experts writing in The Lancet saw the emergence, coincidentally, of a very different four-P medicine: predictive, pre-emptive, personalized and participatory. Quite an upgrade.

The digital deluge has downsides, including anti-vaccination drivel and every kind of quackery. But your generation can access more health information in seconds than most of us in 1978 imagined finding in a lifetime of practice or research. The biotechnology revolution that began in the 1980s has only accelerated. During your careers, information technology converging with bioscience and artificial intelligence will transform health-care processes and outcomes.

Your generation will use tissue engineering and stem-cell technology to grow personalized replacement parts. Transplants, artificial joints and chronic dialysis may disappear. CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing will reverse many scourges, including hereditary anaemias, before or shortly after birth. Every specialty that relies on interpreting images will change dramatically as pattern-recognition software is deployed at scale.

It will not all be smooth sailing. There will be thorny ethical, legal and social questions, challenges of access and affordability, and a real risk of losing sight of the enduring need to invest in public-health protection and address the broad social determinants of health and illness. Yet despite those challenges, I stand here slightly envious of you and deeply excited about what the next forty-one years hold. You are fortunate indeed.

Tradition says the fake graduate should offer advice to the real graduates. I have five quick points.

First, remember that advances in science and technology made you meaningfully better equipped than your counterparts in my generation. Whatever your discipline or practice setting, be vocal champions of basic and applied health research for the rest of your lives. That is a gift you can give the next generation.

Second, whatever you do in health, be relentless advocates for positive change. Press tirelessly for fairness, accessibility, higher quality and safer care. Health systems everywhere are struggling to keep pace with demographic and technological changes over the last twenty-five years, and I am sorry to say that is true across our wonderful country.

Third, even if you cannot always improve the health-care system, you can improve yourself. Keep learning and never stop. Do not rule out retraining to add new skills, or even making a mid-career change to avoid burnout and revive the idealism that I know each of you carries today.

Fourth, the more powerful technology becomes, the more vital it is that health professionals avoid construing the patient as a disembodied digital entity with a disease. Focus on illness as the experience of a fellow traveller on this planet. By leavening expertise with empathy, you will help patients and loved ones build a narrative in which they can locate what is happening during a vulnerable and stressful time.

Last, health care, like everything else in life, is ultimately a team sport. It is increasingly collaborative, multidisciplinary and multi-professional. Individual accountability and leadership still matter, but self-styled solo geniuses fare poorly in health care.

Your prospects for success, resilience after setbacks, career path, happiness and legacy all depend on whom you choose as travelling companions in the decades ahead, and how well you work with companions you did not choose—especially those you never would have chosen.

Fellow graduates, along with an excellent education and today's degree or diploma from this truly great university, you possess the most precious asset of all: the gift of time, with boundless possibilities to make a positive difference as your careers and lives unfold. Congratulations, and warmest wishes for happiness and every success. Thank you for allowing me to share your special day.

署名David Naylor  2019-06-04  published in University of Toronto