Andrew Ross Sorkin: It is my privilege to be here with Jack Ma, one of the great entrepreneurs of our time and, of course, the founder of Alibaba. We have many things to discuss over the next half hour, and we also want to get to your questions. We will talk about Alibaba, China, the Trump world we all live in, globalization, trade and many other issues. Thank you for joining us.
Sorkin: You just visited Trump Tower and met with President-elect Donald Trump. Could you tell us about this meeting?
Ma: This meeting was productive, much better than I expected.
Sorkin: What did you expect?
Ma: Like everyone else, I heard and saw a lot of news about him. After going in, I felt he was open-minded and willing to listen to my views. I'm very happy with the outcome of the conversation. He offered to walk me downstairs, so I think he must also be very happy with the results of this meeting.
Sorkin: Did you call him, or did he call you? How did this meeting come about?
Ma: That's a question I asked myself too. One day, someone asked me if I'd like to meet the President-elect. I said, really? I'm not ready yet, I don't know what to talk about. A few days later, I got several more messages — a friend emailed me asking the same thing.
I thought about it and decided maybe I should go talk, at least Trump might be happy with what I have to say, so I went. We discussed SMEs, agricultural products, China-US trade, especially focusing on letting American businesses sell to Asia through our network, which would create a lot of jobs for them.
Sorkin: You promised to create one million jobs for America in the next five years — not directly hiring by Alibaba?
Ma: Not us hiring. Alibaba has 45,000 employees; we can't hire one million people. I can't even imagine managing one million people.
Sorkin: Please tell us how you see China-US relations, and how do you comment on Trump's previous remarks about China manipulating currency? Did you discuss these during the meeting?
Ma: First of all, there's freedom of speech in America. He can say whatever he wants, and I respect and understand that. But I also have my own views. We won't debate China-US trade, currency manipulation and such, but we reached some consensus: SMEs, developing the Midwest, helping local farmers and SMEs export to China. We won't talk about American jobs being lost to Mexico, China, and so on.
Can I share my view? First, thirty years ago when I had just graduated from college, we heard about America's wonderful strategy of outsourcing manufacturing jobs to Mexico and China, and outsourcing services to India. There's a book called "The World Is Flat" by Thomas Friedman. I think it was a perfect strategy. America said it only wanted to control IP, technology, and brands, and leave lower-level work to the rest of the world — that was a great strategy. Second, American international companies made millions of dollars through globalization.
America's top 100 companies are amazing. When I had just graduated, I wanted to buy a Motorola pager, which cost $250, while my salary was only $10 a month, and the cost of making the pager was just $8. Over the past 30 years, companies like Microsoft, Cisco, and IBM made tens of millions of dollars — more than China's four major banks combined, more than China Mobile, China Unicom, and so on combined. Their market capitalization grew by over 100% in the past 30 years. So where did all that money go?
As a businessman, I care a lot about the balance sheet — where money comes from and where it goes. Over the past 30 years, America spent $14.2 trillion on 13 wars. What if some of that money had been invested in infrastructure and helping white-collar and blue-collar workers? No matter how good your strategy is, you should invest in your people. Not everyone can get into Harvard — I couldn't, for one. We should invest in people who can't afford education.
What also makes me curious is that when I was young, we heard about big American manufacturers like Ford and Boeing, but in the past 20 years, all we hear about is Silicon Valley and Wall Street — money flowed to Wall Street. Then the 2008 financial crisis hit, with $19.2 trillion in losses. That's a huge sum. It wiped out white-collar workers and destroyed 34 million jobs globally. If that money hadn't gone to Wall Street but had been invested in the Midwest, developing industries there, it would have made a big difference.
It's not that other countries stole your jobs. It's your strategy — you didn't think and allocate funds properly. That's my view.
Sorkin: Now we see strong pushback against restructuring globalization. In fact, most of the discussions here in Davos are around this topic. The pushback is happening in America, but President Xi Jinping came to Davos yesterday, and you were also part of his delegation. What do you think of his speech?
Ma: Globalization is a great thing. America is the developed country that taught us how to do globalization. I remember when we joined the WTO around 2001, we were all worried — what if international brands and products come to China, destroy our industries, and take our jobs? You convinced us back then, but 20 years later you say it's a terrible thing. I think globalization is good, but it needs to be improved.
That's what President-elect Trump wants to address. I think globalization should be inclusive. Over the past 30 years, globalization was controlled by 60,000 large companies; 100 years ago, it was controlled by a few kings. What if in the next 30 years we can support 6 million enterprises operating across borders? What if in the next 30 years we can support 20 million SMEs operating across borders? We believe globalization should be inclusive.
Sorkin: Do you think what President Xi mentioned will happen? China has represented the East for many years. Now, if America continues to act on behalf of everyone?
Ma: President Xi mentioned yesterday that this is the best of times and the worst of times. The world needs new leaders, but new leaders means working together — that's my understanding. A new leader doesn't need to be one specific person who teaches everyone what can and can't be done. But the world needs to stand together. As a Chinese businessman, I really like and am proud of what President Xi said yesterday. As a businessman, I hope the whole world can share responsibility and cooperate; as a Chinese person, I'm also happy about the commitments he made.
Yesterday he mentioned that China, as the world's second-largest economy, should take on responsibility. This is the first time I've heard a Chinese leader make a quantitative commitment. He said our imports will reach $8 trillion in the next five years. That excites me, because China is transitioning from export to import. If we can achieve a concrete numerical target, it will be a huge transformation for China and the world.
Sorkin: Today China is relatively more interested in globalization, because the benefits it brings will continue to support China's growth toward a "developed country." What do you think?
Ma: First, the WTO rules were not made by China, nor were they made for China. What I want to change is that in the past, the WTO was designed for large companies; only large companies could participate. China has also benefited greatly from opening up. I think China needs to learn one thing — China was able to grow in the past because we opened up to the world. If we can continue to open up... that's why I say China also has its problems.
This world has problems, and China certainly has many of its own. China should be more open, more confident, and so on. President Xi's words yesterday gave me confidence — he's ready to open China further to the world. That's my suggestion. We should solve problems through business communities and through negotiations. China has been in the WTO for over a decade. I think whether as a company, as a country, or as the whole world, we need to re-examine. Not just because of imbalances — we can call a stop.
Sorkin: You proposed eWTP. What exactly is it?
Ma: The WTO is great, but it was mainly designed for developed countries and their companies. SMEs have no chance. We want to establish eWTP, the Electronic World Trade Platform, to support young people and SMEs, who can buy and sell across borders online through their phones and the internet. Also, the WTO is a very interesting institution.
It can get 20 governments to come together and reach a consensus on one thing — that's almost impossible. I can't imagine the parties reaching consensus. Business should be decided by businesspeople. I think eWTP should be something where businesspeople sit down to discuss, negotiate, and reach consensus, and then get government support.
Sorkin: About Alibaba and your own business model — I think most Westerners may not quite understand it. Can I try to compare you with Amazon? You might feel this comparison is unfair. But one thing I find very interesting is that what Amazon pursues, it seems to me, is more of an asset-heavy business model — they buy planes, want to own the entire supply chain.
Alibaba, in terms of retail, is the opposite — you don't want to run your own warehouses or your own logistics company. What do you think? Is Jeff Bezos right, are you right, or will you meet in the middle?
Ma: I hope both sides are right, because the world doesn't have just one business model. If the world only had one "correct" business model, it would be very boring. We need all kinds of models, and people working toward a model must believe in that model. I believe in what I'm doing. As for the difference with Amazon — Amazon is more like an empire, controlling everything from buying to selling.
Our philosophy is to build an ecosystem. Our philosophy is to empower others, help them sell and serve, make sure they can be more powerful than us, make sure our partners, 100,000 brands and SMEs can compete with Microsoft and IBM because of our technology and innovation. We believe that through internet technology, we can make every company an Amazon.
Last year our GMV exceeded $550 billion. If we had to hire employees to deliver all these goods, we'd need 5 million people. We can't hire 5 million people to deliver the goods sold on our platform. The only way is to empower service companies and logistics companies, making sure they can operate efficiently, make profits, and hire more people.
Sorkin: If you don't own the supply chain, can you guarantee efficiency? Amazon can now deliver to homes within hours.
Ma: Last year we achieved same-day delivery in 125 cities in China. Ten years ago, mailing from Beijing to Hangzhou took 8 days. Now it takes 12 hours to deliver from Beijing to cities in Inner Mongolia. Logistics efficiency has improved. You can't expect such progress overnight. We have enough patience. On 2016's Double 11, we sold $17 billion worth of goods on our platform, and within 3 days we delivered a total of 600 million packages.
This is what's happening, and what we're proud of — not how much money we make, but how much power we have. We can make technology more inclusive, so every small business can use it. That's my dream. In 1992 I founded my first company in China, a small company. To borrow $5,000 from a bank, I spent 3 months applying and still failed. Being a small business is really hard. Today, with the development of technology, we can empower. That's what I want to do.
Sorkin: One ongoing criticism of Alibaba is the issue of infringement. Intellectual property is a big problem in China, but Alibaba is a major target of criticism. What progress do you think Alibaba has made, and how do you view regulators in other countries, including America, still questioning Alibaba?
Ma: First, when you have such a large-scale business, you must learn to accept criticism. You must listen, then judge which is right and which is wrong. Second, as an e-commerce platform empowering 10 million small merchants, we don't operate like Amazon Buy. Especially with $550 billion worth of traded goods, you can't check everything. That's a problem inherent in the e-commerce model itself.
Third, over the past 17 years, we've been a leader in fighting counterfeits and protecting IP. But we're an internet company with no law enforcement power. When we find someone selling fakes, we can remove them from the platform, but we can't arrest them. Last year alone, we helped put 400 counterfeiters in prison, and we took down 370 million counterfeit items. We're not just leaders in fighting fakes — we use big data to fight them.
We're glad that governments around the world, especially Chinese government agencies, are now aware of this problem. The good thing is that today, if you ask these "criminal gangs" — the counterfeiters and sellers — they say they can go to any platform but now dare not go on Taobao or Tmall, because our big data technology can find out who they are and where they are, and submit it to the police to catch them.
Sorkin: You said something before about the quality of counterfeit goods?
Ma: What I said about the quality of counterfeits was not praise for fakes. It's that after all these years, these brand companies must be very careful, because the quality of counterfeits is improving dramatically, which is terrifying. That's the difference.
You find a counterfeiter, someone says this is fake, you go to a third party to authenticate whether it's fake, and sometimes you find the fake is better quality. What's even scarier is that a brand company says you're selling fakes, we searched for a long time to find problems but couldn't, then we bought a product from the flagship store and sent it for testing, and they said it's fake. It's very confusing.
Fighting counterfeits is a battle against human greed. It's not easy at all, and it can never be ended, but we must keep fighting. Every year we invest 2,000 dedicated personnel and 1 billion RMB in fighting counterfeits. It's impossible to end this war in two years. If people keep criticizing, what matters is that we ourselves are happy with the progress.
If people praise me, saying "Jack Ma, you're great!" I know I'm not really great. Or "Alibaba is great!" We're not great — we're just a 17-year-old company. But if they say you've done nothing on counterfeits — no, we're doing a lot. But you don't need to argue, you just do what you believe in.
Sorkin: You talked about using big data in fighting counterfeits. On the other hand, you also use big data in your credit system, enabling people who can't get loans to get loans. We talked about Sesame Credit. In a market where some people have no credit history, how do you determine who can get a loan and who shouldn't?
Ma: First, before this, we had a system that taught computers how to identify counterfeits and fraud on Alipay. We've been doing this for ten years. Now people call it AI — artificial intelligence. We're a data company. Eight years ago, we told ourselves we can't be just an e-commerce company; we want to be a data company.
We have data on consumers, manufacturers, logistics, transactions, and so on. But how to use this data to benefit society? Many Chinese small businesses are very good, with good credit, but there's no credit system suitable for them. How to use our data to build a credit system so everyone can access it?
This has been very powerful over the past four years. Everyone who uses our services gets a credit rating. Over the past 5 years, we've made 5 million small business loans, even if they only ask for a $5,000 loan. In 3 minutes we can decide whether to lend and how much, and the money arrives in 1 second, without anyone needing to contact them.
We call this "310." Sesame Credit can also be used as capital for dating — a mother-in-law might say to her future son-in-law, if you want to date my daughter, show me your Sesame Credit score. If people want to rent a car, they'll also be asked to show their Sesame Credit score. If they don't repay, their credit score goes down and they might not be able to rent. That's the system we want to build. If you buy or sell fakes, it will also show up in Sesame Credit.
Sorkin: Last question — there's been a lot of speculation about your foray into Hollywood. Your name and Alibaba's name appeared in several blockbusters earlier this year. What are Alibaba's ambitions in Hollywood?
Ma: Every five years, we do a strategic review, looking ahead 30 years and 10 years. For all strategic questions, we ask ourselves one thing: does it solve a social problem? We believe the more social problems you solve, the more successful you are. The second question: will this project succeed within ten years?
If so, we do it. If it can succeed in a month or a year? Then don't do it. How could it succeed in a month or a year? Five years ago, we had a big debate about what China needs most in the next 10 and 20 years. Finally we decided on happiness and health — the "Double H" strategy.
Hollywood movies can bring people happiness. Right now no one is happy — rich people aren't happy, poor people aren't happy. At least watching movies can make people happy. I think we should cooperate with Hollywood. China has many heroes, but Chinese heroes always die, while American heroes never die. If all heroes die, who would want to be a hero? I want my heroes to survive.
We should learn more from that. We've only been at it for 2 years, with 8 years to go. I want my company to be more than just e-commerce — to give people inspiration. I get a lot of inspiration from movies. My favorite movie is "Forrest Gump." Life is hard — that's what I learned from it, and I got a lot of inspiration. Over the past 17 years, people said I was crazy and stupid.
"You're crazy, doing impossible things!" "You're an idiot, how can you do this model when Amazon has this model, eBay has that model — why does Alibaba have this model?" I said to myself, Forrest Gump says, just keep going, don't care what others think. Forrest Gump also said nobody makes money easily — people make money by catching shrimp. So, we serve small businesses.
Andrew Ross Sorkin: Jack, we should probably end there because we are running out of time. Thank you for the conversation. I promised we would squeeze in a question or two, so please make it very quick.
Audience member: Do you think China and the United States will enter a trade war? If the Trump administration starts one, will Alibaba be affected?
Jack Ma: China and the United States should never have a trade war. We should give President-elect Donald Trump some time. He is open-minded and he listens. It is easy to launch a war, but very difficult—sometimes almost impossible—to end one. Look at the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. Are they finished? No. I believe that when trade stops, war starts. Trade gets people communicating and exchanging cultures and values.
Jack Ma: If China and the United States reached an agreement that destroyed Alibaba's business model, I would destroy that model if doing so could stop a trade war. How can the world's largest and second-largest economies have a trade war? It would be a disaster for both countries and the world. If anybody can do something to stop it, they should do anything they can.
Andrew Ross Sorkin: What was your reaction to President-elect Trump and the situation with Taiwan?
Jack Ma: Taiwan is not only a question of government or business; it is about the people. If you mishandle the Taiwan issue, it is like going against 1.4 billion people. That is a different issue. We are talking about trade, not Taiwan.
Andrew Ross Sorkin: Very diplomatic. Let us take one final question.
Jack Ma: I am not a politician.
Audience member: How do you ensure that you are not disrupting people's lives or dictating the whole credit system, when you are now making the decisions and the rules?
Jack Ma: I am not sure. People say this is an uncertain world, but every day is uncertain; the only certain day was yesterday. If I thought I could dictate the future, I would be stupid. That is why I should retire early while I am young. I dream of doing many things: becoming a philanthropist and a teacher, returning to school and working on the environment. The world is wonderful. Why should I remain Alibaba's CEO all the time? I did not come into this world only to work. I want to enjoy life. I do not want to die in my office; I want to die on a beach.
Andrew Ross Sorkin: That is a wonderful message. Jack, thank you for the conversation.
Jack Ma: May I give one final message?
Andrew Ross Sorkin: Yes, please.
Ma: Can I say a few final words? I want to give everyone here one last suggestion — all governments need to pay attention: the next 30 years are very important for the world. Every technological revolution takes 50 years — the first 20 years technology companies emerge, the next 30 years technology gets applied. So let's focus on the next 30 years. In the previous 20 years, eBay, Amazon, Facebook, Alibaba, Google emerged...
that's great, but the most important thing is to make technology inclusive and change the world — that's the next 30 years. Let's pay attention to people who are 30 years old, because they're the internet generation, they will change the world and become its builders. Third, let's pay attention to small businesses that may have fewer than 30 employees. 30-year-old people and 30-person companies will make the world a better place.
Sorkin: Thank you very much, Mr. Jack Ma. Thank you!