Moderator: Hello and welcome, everyone. It is my pleasure to introduce our distinguished guest for today's Meet the Leader session. Jack Ma began his professional life as a teacher and has called himself the unlikeliest of technology entrepreneurs. He is executive chairman of Alibaba Group, the leading e-commerce and technology conglomerate headquartered in China.
Moderator: On April 4 this year, Alibaba will celebrate its twentieth birthday. It was founded in 1999 by Jack and seventeen former students in his living room. Jack believed technology could level the playing field for businesses worldwide. Alibaba has transformed tens of millions of lives in China, created more than thirty million jobs, and recorded 1.4 billion transactions—90 percent through mobile—on Singles' Day last November. Its ambition is to create 100 million jobs and reach two billion consumers globally.
Moderator: Jack first came to Davos as a Young Global Leader in 2001 and now serves on the boards of the World Economic Forum and the Global Shapers Community. We are fortunate that he made time to meet the Forum's young communities. Please give Jack a warm welcome. Today, Global Shapers, Young Global Leaders, and Technology Pioneers are eager to engage with you.
Moderator: In 1999, you recorded a speech to your co-founders at Alibaba's launch. You seemed resolute and confident that the company would succeed, yet there is no risk-free business. Did you experience doubt or fear? Did you worry that you might not make it? If so, how did you manage those fears, and what support system did you have?
Jack Ma: Thank you. It is a great honor to be with you. I know many people here are strong in technology, so please do not ask me technical questions. Of course I was scared. I had fear and doubt again and again. But I never doubted that somebody would win. If it was not us or me, somebody else would do it.
Jack Ma: In 1999, the internet was at an early stage and everybody had a fair chance. There were no experts then. There are no experts of tomorrow; there are only experts of yesterday. Nobody can tell you exactly what tomorrow will be like.
Jack Ma: We did not have a system that could help me overcome doubt and fear. I tried to be transparent with my team. I told them what I worried about and where I was uncertain. If they knew I was hiding my worries, they would worry even more. I could not make the team worry with me all day, so after going home I thought harder, learned, and gained experience.
Jack Ma: When you are young and still want to accomplish something, opportunities exist if you create value. What worries you is that somebody may do it better, faster, or more skillfully and take the chance. My rule in business is: never fear competition or pressure. If you cannot face pressure and competition, do not become an entrepreneur.
Jack Ma: The world worries about data, privacy, security, and almost everything. Usually, where there is worry, a great opportunity appears. You cannot stop the internet, mobile technology, or big data. Embrace them and change yourself. No system can make you stop worrying—not even a president has one. Human beings have doubts. The difference is whether you fix the problem, change yourself, and fight again tomorrow.
Moderator: You spoke about being transparent with your team. Many of us are building businesses and organizations and hope to create a similar or even greater impact. How did you build your team, and how did you know you had the right people?
Jack Ma: People now imagine Alibaba's eighteen founders were legendary or extraordinary. Honestly, most of us could not find good jobs. We were not that smart, and none graduated from a great university. But we were ready to learn, believed in the future, and believed that if we worked and improved together, we would get there.
Jack Ma: I told them in the first year to forget about becoming vice presidents. If we succeeded, we would hire people smarter than us; if we hired only people less capable than ourselves, we would be in trouble. When you hire smarter people, the company grows, and you should be happy because that serves the mission.
Jack Ma: There is no perfect person already waiting for you. The best person becomes the right person by working with you: you train and develop them, and they train and develop you. Never assume somebody must be excellent simply because they once worked at Google, Alibaba, or Facebook. Not necessarily.
Moderator: What minimum qualities do you look for before bringing somebody onto your team?
Jack Ma: First, the person should be smart. Stupidity is worse than cancer: cancer may be cured, but stupidity is very difficult to cure. I hire people smarter than I am. I want somebody who, in four or five years, could become my boss—someone I would be happy to work for.
Jack Ma: Second, I look at personality. I like positive people who do not easily give up. I do not care much which university somebody attended. What matters is that the person is smart, has a character you like, and never gives up.
Jack Ma: I have met excellent leaders in many fields. They are optimistic and do not complain about other people or circumstances. They may say, “I was not smart enough,” or “I did not think clearly, so I must change.” They complain about themselves, not others. If someone constantly complains about everybody and the outside world, do not hire or work with that person.
Moderator: As a Nigerian entrepreneur, I am intrigued by your comments on Africa's potential. You recently met President Paul Kagame of Rwanda and committed ten million US dollars to the Netpreneur Prize. What sparked your interest in African technology entrepreneurs?
Jack Ma: My first visit to Africa was in 2017. Before that, I worried about poverty, disease, safety, and security. Finally I decided to see it myself and visited Kenya, Rwanda, and Namibia. What I found was completely different from what I had imagined. It felt like China twenty years ago when I started my business: young people were passionate and hopeful about the future.
Jack Ma: Europe often worries about the future because it wants to preserve yesterday. Africa may have less of a yesterday to preserve, so people are optimistic and eager for the future. Successful people are the hardest to convince and change. Africa wants change, has many young people, and has poor infrastructure—which means opportunity.
Jack Ma: Mobile phones grew so fast in China because fixed-line service had been poor. Few families had a telephone, so when mobile arrived, everybody embraced it. Africa has the same opportunity and smart young people. I would focus on four things. The first is internet technology. The internet is inclusive: unlike credit cards, which first reached the wealthy, mobile payments can immediately reach young and poor people.
Jack Ma: The second focus is entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs will change Africa because they have courage and are not afraid of the future. If you only worry about the future, you cannot be a good entrepreneur; you must believe something will happen and prepare for it. The third is education. Western education is strong, but its system was designed two hundred years ago for the industrial age. The data age needs innovation and creativity.
Jack Ma: The fourth is infrastructure, so everyone can reach the internet and use a phone not only for games or Twitter but to buy, sell, communicate, and do business. E-government is also crucial. Put government online and it must become more transparent; it cannot shut down the internet without shutting down itself. These are opportunities for developing countries to leapfrog.
Moderator: I will now open the floor. Please introduce yourself and your community. Do not pitch to Jack Ma, however tempting that may be, and keep your question succinct so everyone has a chance.
Questioner (Young Global Leader, Sweden): Education systems were designed for earlier industrial revolutions. As we design new organizations and educational systems, how should leadership change? What kind of leadership does the new economy need?
Jack Ma: Education has huge potential, but most universities and business schools will face challenges. Developing countries such as China, India, and those in Africa put many resources into PhDs, master's degrees, and research institutes. I believe we should put more resources into the earlier stages: kindergarten, primary school, and middle school.
Jack Ma: Past education trained children as learning and calculating machines, filling their heads with facts. If you compete with a computer at remembering or calculating, you have no chance. A computer does not forget and works whenever it has electricity. We must teach children to be creative and innovative and to do what machines cannot do.
Jack Ma: When you have many smart people, leadership becomes the key. To lead smart people, use culture and values they believe in. Rules, laws, documents, and control may manage less capable people, but the next generation should be educated, smart, and wiser than machines. Alibaba is like a zoo with every kind of animal. The best management is self-management.
Jack Ma: People manage themselves when they believe in values and a mission. Machines in the future will have chips, but human beings have hearts. The heart contains values and mission. Education must move in that direction.
Questioner (Global Shaper, Doha): How is Alibaba making its supply chains more sustainable and responding to climate change? How should young business leaders act on climate and the environment?
Jack Ma: As a technology company, we believe technology is good for humanity and can create many jobs. Every technological revolution has ultimately created more jobs, but in its early stage it creates worry. If it is not managed well, it can cause disaster. The first technological revolution contributed to the First World War, the second to the Second World War, and now the third is arriving.
Jack Ma: Alibaba has confidence in the future. We believe technology should be inclusive and sustainable and can help solve environmental problems. We have only one Earth. If Earth were a person, digging out oil and coal and burning them would be like taking things from its body; the Earth would respond painfully.
Jack Ma: We still need oil, coal, and wood, but data can tell us how to use resources efficiently and intelligently. We also need to give every person and every country the opportunity to participate. I am not a technology expert, but I firmly believe technology can benefit humanity.
Jack Ma: For a technology company, “do not be evil” is not enough. It should actively do good for the world and the future and believe in young people. Climate change and the environment are huge challenges. The planet may have comfortably supported three billion people; now we have more than seven billion and may reach ten or twelve billion. Use technology to foresee future problems and start solving them now.
Jack Ma: Alibaba has much more to do than make money. Profit was important when the company began, but now the question is how technology can improve the world and make development inclusive, sustainable, growing, and green. That is why, instead of resting, we continue working and fighting. That is the meaning of technology.
Questioner (Global Shaper): The Forum talks often about skills for the future of work. What about skills for the future of humanity? I believe empathy and mindfulness may be the most relevant skills, though they are not the usual hard or soft skills we discuss.
Jack Ma: Alibaba has six values, and two of them are unique and should never change. The first says: customers first, employees second, shareholders third. It means enabling others and making other people better. One reason we survived for twenty years is that I was a teacher. A teacher always wants students to become more successful than the teacher.
Jack Ma: The first rule for humanity is to help your parents, children, and colleagues do better than you. The second value is embracing change. Whatever arrives—even what you did not expect—embrace it if you cannot change it. Leaders and anyone who wants to serve should make others better and embrace change. When people worry or complain, ask whether solving that worry creates an opportunity.
Questioner (millennial entrepreneur): Millennials are often criticized for changing jobs quickly. Would you recommend job-hopping, or should young people stay for several years and learn?
Jack Ma: One experience changed me greatly. I trained to be a teacher and originally hated the idea. Under China's system then, if you trained as a teacher, you had to teach. On graduation day, the university president stopped me at the gate and asked me to promise not to leave my assigned school for six years. I agreed.
Jack Ma: I taught at a university for six years. I calmed down, learned to teach, communicated with young students, changed my mind, and discovered the good in being a teacher. Many opportunities appeared during those six years, but I declined them because I had promised. Only after six years did I leave and begin my internet career.
Jack Ma: Your first job after graduation is the most important. It need not be at a famous company. Find a good boss who teaches you how to be a human being, do things properly, and think correctly. Promise yourself you will stay for at least three years before moving. Constantly changing jobs leads to many mistakes and disasters. Stay focused on one thing.
Jack Ma: From twenty to thirty, you have many ideas and think you can do everything, but you may accomplish little. Follow one good person. From thirty to forty, if you truly want to do something yourself, try it. From forty to fifty, focus on what you are good at. From fifty to sixty, enable young people to do better. After sixty, spend time with your grandchildren and enjoy yourself. That is the normal course of life.
Questioner (bank executive, Jamaica): Technology democratizes access to markets, which matters to small and poorer countries. But innovation has no common standard, and these countries could be left behind. Should innovation be standardized and managed globally to ensure inclusive growth?
Jack Ma: This is what I work on almost every day. Small companies and developing countries should not begin by thinking about standards, rules, and regulation. First, let entrepreneurs and innovation emerge. Once they exist, you will understand how to regulate them.
Jack Ma: The last century favored big scale, big money, and standardization. This century favors personalization and customization. Debating global standards can take years, while entrepreneurs can create major change in three to five years. Developing countries should not copy Europe's long regulatory debates. When larger countries are worrying and talking, smaller countries have an opportunity to move faster.
Questioner (Global Shaper, Pune): The Global Shapers community gives me a place to be vulnerable and share fears and failures. With whom do you feel safe doing that? Are Alibaba's eighteen co-founders still the people with whom you share your fears?
Jack Ma: Young Global Leaders and Global Shapers form a very good community. I came here in 2001 as a Young Global Leader. I sat and listened to Bill Gates and Kofi Annan debate. I did not understand most of it, but I went home and tested the parts I did understand. Davos helped reform me. If I could do only one thing here each year, it would be spending time with young Global Shapers and sharing what I have learned.
Jack Ma: You can be friends, but be cautious about doing business together. I have seen business-school classmates become partners and then lose both the friendship and the business. From a distance, people look wonderful; close up, things differ. Business is like a marriage, but it is not a marriage. Friendship can be more precious because a friend can remain outside the company and give honest advice.
Jack Ma: I remain in contact with Alibaba's eighteen founders. On our tenth anniversary, I asked every founder to submit a resignation that night. I told them the company owed them nothing: they had worked hard and received what they wanted. If they wished to return, they had forty-eight hours to think and then had to apply as ordinary employees. We would no longer treat them as founders, and anyone unqualified would leave.
Jack Ma: Many companies encounter trouble because founders assume permanent privilege. I am proud that all eighteen live well and remain in contact. But when I face trouble, I also have friends from many industries and backgrounds. I believe deeply in friendship. If a friend commits a crime, that person should be punished, but remains my friend. If they change after prison, I will support them. Friendship is not about how successful somebody is; it is about who gives honest advice when you are in trouble.
Questioner (Global Shaper, Egypt): What keeps you awake at night in today's world?
Jack Ma: Nothing. I sleep very well. You get used to it. People see the good side of a company like Alibaba, but there have been many frightening moments and worries that we had to overcome again and again. I learned that if I cannot sleep, the problem will still be there. If I sleep well, I have a chance to fight it tomorrow.
Jack Ma: No matter what happens, sleep well. When I wake up, I go to Africa, Europe, or a United Nations panel and say what I believe. Whether people accept it is less important than telling the truth and offering your opinion. Then act and try to change things. Do not only worry.
Questioner (Global Shaper, Hong Kong): Many students have no idea what they want to do because school and the real world focus on different things. Could the private sector, perhaps Alibaba, build a curriculum or school where younger students learn entrepreneurship, e-commerce, and twenty-first-century skills?
Jack Ma: I have already created a kindergarten, primary school, middle school, and high school. We must test change instead of only talking about it. In China, parents chase schools that produce high test scores. We interview parents and warn them that our students may not perform like children in conventional schools. We ask whether they are still willing to enroll them.
Jack Ma: At first people said nobody would come. I did not worry; Alibaba has forty thousand employees in Hangzhou. When people asked what would happen if our primary graduates could not enter middle school, I said we would build a middle school. If they could not enter high school, we would build one. I do not worry about university. In ten years, universities will want students trained as real human beings rather than learning machines.
Jack Ma: In kindergarten, teach singing and dancing and plant the seeds of culture. In primary school, teach values from both East and West. I do not want children educated in the West to dislike the East, or children educated in the East to dislike the West. Some criticize China without reading Buddhism, Daoism, or Confucius; others criticize the West without reading the Bible. How can you judge what you do not know?
Jack Ma: In middle school, students should work hard and learn discipline. In high school, they should build interests. Too many high-school students have only one dream—the university their parents chose—and cannot answer what they themselves want. We must change that. Applications to our schools are large, though we accept only about one hundred students each year. We have not yet proved the model will succeed in ten years, but teaching children to be real human beings gives them a chance; training them as machines does not.
Questioner (Young Global Leader, Singapore): You once told me not to study businesses that succeed, but those that fail. If you were Jack Ma starting a new company from scratch in 2019, what would you do, and how would you apply what twenty years of failure taught you?
Jack Ma: If I started again today, I would not enter the internet; too many smart people are already there. I might enter agriculture. Experience means that when a problem comes, I do not panic. I pause, ask what the worst outcome could be, determine whom I need, and examine why the mistake happened and how to face it.
Jack Ma: Young people who want to become business leaders should not only follow stars of success. Successful people benefited from many different reasons, but failures are often alike. Study failure not because you can avoid every mistake, but because when failure arrives, you will know how to face it.
Jack Ma: In another life I would again become a businessperson. A good life is not measured by money or fame, but by the experiences you have encountered. I am proud of the tough situations my team overcame together and the foolish mistakes we can now laugh about. We are writing them down to share with others. Do not laugh too quickly—you may make the same silly mistakes.
Questioner (Global Shaper, Saudi Arabia): The Middle East, like Africa, needs entrepreneurs as it moves away from oil dependence. What do you advise, does Alibaba plan to expand there, and can the region absorb more entrepreneurial projects?
Jack Ma: There are great entrepreneurs everywhere. The West has many professional managers; developing regions such as Africa, the Middle East, China, and India have many natural entrepreneurs. If a government wants the economy to grow, it should not trust only itself. It should trust the market, which means trusting entrepreneurship.
Jack Ma: Governments should invest resources in training, developing, and encouraging entrepreneurs and create business-friendly policies. I have visited several Middle Eastern countries and found excellent entrepreneurs. The problem is that some oil-rich governments are so wealthy that they do not pay attention to small businesses. That is a mistake.
Jack Ma: Last century, bigger was better; this century, small can be better. Last century, a company had to be strong; this century, it should be good. A good company cares for employees, families, friends, and customers. It need not become Alibaba, Amazon, or Microsoft. Build a company that lets you enjoy life. We came into the world not only to build a career but to live. When a company is good, it can become strong. The Middle East has huge potential, but it must embrace technology.
Questioner (Global Shaper): What is your main personal goal, and what do you want to learn in the next five years?
Jack Ma: In business, I hope the internet can build an ecosystem that enables every young person and small business to buy globally, sell globally, deliver globally, pay globally, and travel globally—making the world genuinely global. Personally, we cannot choose the family into which we are born, but we can choose how we live and perhaps how we die. I do not want to die in an office or hospital; I would rather die peacefully on a beach.
Jack Ma: I want to relax and do things I like. I worked extremely hard for fifty years and will continue to work hard, but I will choose work I love. Those fifty years of difficult work earned me the right to do what I want rather than only what I have to do.
Questioner (Young Global Leader, China): China has played catch-up for a long time, and its entrepreneurs can now reach the top globally, but the climb often costs them family, friends, and health. They are too busy to discuss the purpose and values behind technology and economic development. How can this conversation begin in China, help the world understand China, and help China contribute to the world?
Questioner (Global Shaper, Venezuela): Please share a challenge you faced and how you embraced it. Many of us face domestic and other challenges. What enabled you to overcome challenges differently from others?
Jack Ma: China is developing quickly. To become a global leader is not about money, economic power, or military power. It is about responsibility and the value you bring to the world. We call somebody a leader not because the person has strong muscles, but because the person has wisdom, a heart, and knows what they are doing.
Jack Ma: China is learning this. Twenty years ago, when I began my business, I never thought about these questions. As Alibaba reached a certain size, I accepted more responsibility and began to think differently. When you think about creating value for others, you also create value for yourself.
Jack Ma: Current friction between China and the West can be useful if both sides remain rational and learn from one another. Today they sometimes speak like a duck and a chicken—different languages—but conflict is not necessarily bad if it helps understanding. China, the West, the Middle East, and Africa are all learning. We must keep learning, and then things will change.
Jack Ma: I have faced many challenges. Some are so painful and regrettable that I may never discuss them, perhaps until I reach a certain age. The only solution is to go to bed, sleep, wake up, and do it again. Life is short. You may live eighty or one hundred years, but perhaps only thirty are available for your main work. If you remain in a bad mood, you cannot seize the next opportunity.
Jack Ma: Life is also long, so do not believe today's rejection is the end. When many people rejected me, I told myself that somebody smart enough to appreciate me was waiting around the next corner. Stay optimistic and comfort yourself with your own hands. Nobody else can truly warm you; you must warm yourself. If you want to be successful, be ready to pay a hard price. Thank you.