Earl Warren's 1964 Stanford Commencement Address: Keeping Anger at Injustice Alive

It is a great pleasure for me to come back to California where growth and the problems of growth are so evident and where it is obvious that they are being given recognition. There are so many places in the world today where problems have become so overwhelming because underlying conditions have been permitted to exist unattacked, not only for years, but in some cases for generations and even centuries. The result has been problems of stagnation.

There is a great difference between problems of growth and problems of stagnation. The former, if attacked with enthusiasm and vision, can be solved in a positive way. The latter lend themselves only to despair and frustration. The growth of communities, states, and nations must be met with the same principles of husbandry that are recognized by the good farmer.

He realizes that his soil must be prepared, weeds removed, trees trimmed, crops harvested, and the land continually fertilized and enriched to maintain the ingredients that are essential to healthy growth. The farmer knows that the only growth that is rewarding is that which comes from day-to-day and year-to-year planning and attention. And cities, states, and nations like farms have crops that must be cultivated but with infinitely more care. For these crops are people.

Yes, I am happy to come home where there is so much evidence that my state is conscious of the problems of its growth and in so many respects is making prodigious efforts to meet the challenges presented. For me one of the most exciting things about California today is what is happening in education. Only recently I read that in our State there are now 629,000 registered college students, a figure which is higher than that of any other State in the Union.

New York of approximately the same population comes next with 415,000, then Illinois with 242,000, and Texas and Pennsylvania follow, with 233,000 and 230,000, respectively. I inquired further and found that California also leads the entire nation now in the number of students enrolled in full-time elementary and secondary schools. There are almost 4 million such pupils in this State now. New York, the runner-up, has just barely over 3 million.

Equally gratifying is that California is at the top of the list also in the average salary paid to its dedicated teachers. When I reflect upon these figures and comparisons my mind goes back to almost 20 years ago. At about that time we first became aware of the size of our crop of wartime babies and began to anticipate the educational necessities of 1965. I can recall very well with what fervor the educators of our state started to make plans for the future and to anticipate the coming problems.

These they faced not with alarm or despair, but with vigorous determination to meet the situation realistically. The figures I have mentioned bear partial witness to the success of their efforts. But figures alone do not tell the whole story, for the quality of the education which students are receiving in California is second to none. I remember, too, counselling with your great President, Dr. Sterling, when we were making our plans almost two decades ago.

I take this opportunity to note that no educator of our day has been more farsighted or more effective in achieving the desired academic goals than Wallace Sterling. I regret sincerely that he cannot be with us today, but I feel confident that a few months of relaxation from his arduous duties will restore the dynamic vigor and enthusiasm that are so characteristic of him. I know how proud he would be to witness this ceremony and to gaze upon you, the handiwork of his efforts.

I need hardly say that, although I was educated across the Bay at another great university, I am as thrilled as any of you to see what is happening here at Stanford. The pioneer spirit of your founders is still so much in evidence that one cannot escape the thrill that comes with daring accomplishment. New methods, new techniques, new financing, are constantly being used, but the same courageous and farsighted spirit of those who had the vision to settle and develop this area and this university remains.

I am thinking not only of what has been done right here at Palo Alto. But I think of your projects overseas—in Germany, Italy, France, Japan, and Taiwan as being true pioneering efforts in the same tradition and spirit as motivated Senator Stanford and his wife to come West. Some people scoff at the idea of pioneering in this day and age.

They think that the world has fully developed and that there is no longer any possibility of exploring because there is no new land to open up—because there are no new horizons to reach for. This attitude reminds me of a pronouncement made by Henry L. Ellsworth, the first Commissioner of Patents. He observed in an annual report that "the advancement of the arts, from year to year, taxes our credulity and seems to presage the arrival of that period when human improvements must end." It was 120 years ago that Mr.

Ellsworth made that doleful prediction. Imagine what developments have occurred since that time. Warren speech 2-2-2 The fact is that your generation has as much opportunity to pioneer and make new advances as any generation that ever lived. Your chances for adventure are as great as those of the Argonauts who crossed the country on horseback or in prairie schooners. Like yourselves, they were young people who felt the challenge; who had the vision and daring to chart new courses and strike out in new directions.

You may recall the saying of those days that "the timid never started and the weak died on the way." Those who made it were neither timid nor weak, nor is this generation. Today, as then, the race is to those who have the vision, the courage, and the stamina to run it. True, there are some differences between the early pioneers and yourselves, their modern counterpart. Their horizons were limited by the distant mountains and the setting sun; yours are limited only by the confines of the mind itself.

And what thrilling horizons are those which you pursue! Modern pioneers must also have the strength to reshape our world in the light of modern scientific development and to see that our social Institutions keep pace with scientific progress. If we stop to reflect, the greatest developments of science in the history of the world have come during your lifetime. And your adjustment to this progress has been more normal than has been the case with your elders.

To us the recent advances in electronics, space, light, nuclear energy, and even genetics, are staggering. To many they are frightening. To you these advances, and many more, are already a part of your life. They are now the preoccupation of people of your age throughout the world. Yet little of these matters is comprehended, except by a relatively few of those of my generation. It is a new age. it is your age.

During your lifetime, also, the greatest effort yet made in human history has been to solve the problems of the world by negotiation and agreement rather than by force. This is the mission of the United Nations, which was born in your lifetime. Its progress has been slow, sometimes halting, but the foundation has been laid, basic principles have been established. You can build the structure. What good for human kind there is to be accomplished through such an agency. What a frontier!

In this same period—and ! speak of your lifetime—our country has come to realize that as long as poverty exists anywhere in the world it affects our own security. We are now aware that the dignity of man—of all men—and his right to a place in the sun is the focal concern of our time. What a frontier this is! The cause of equal justice under law is being pressed throughout our land, and an awareness of the equality of mankind is pervasive everywhere. A peaceful revolution is taking place.

But we cannot take its peaceful character for granted. Where wrongs are not righted and injustices are not corrected, emotion often supplants reason. This is an age-old problem but one with new dimensions. I have every confidence that you will approach the problems which face you with greater resolution, better understanding, more sympathy and mature wisdom than has been done in the past. So I have very little advice to give you, except for these few observations.

The free institutions under which we live will remain free for you only as long as you choose to keep them so. Every generation must re-establish its own freedom and must re-dedicate itself anew to the principles by which we live. But dangers are ever present. These are not just dangers of external aggression, but the dangers that stem from indifference, selfishness, greed, and from the preoccupation with only material things. These are the dangers that corrode the rights and opportunities of people.

Our battle today is to keep our concepts of equality and freedom from eroding just as Americans in every past period of our history were obliged to struggle for theirs. There must never be any surcease from vigilance. I would also remind you that we live in a pluralistic society made up of people of diverse races, colors, religions, and that our great ideal has been to bring about unity through diversity.

All true union is the integration of diversity, just as every physical structure is the integration of various materials contributing their respective qualities and attributes to make a totality. If every unit were alike it would form merely a mass, an ineffective pile. The union that is strength, the union that is functional, the union that has quality, is the union of the diverse.

Warren speech 3-3-3 It has been hard for human beings to learn this lesson, and all through the ages they have paid a heavy price for rejecting it. Group pride, group rapacity, the assertion of superiority, the fear of change, have always fought against it. Our way, each group has asserted, is the only right way; our truth is the only truth.

It was believed in earlier days that people who had different religious faiths could not be citizens of the same country, and persecutions, violent discords, wars of religion were the consequences, with wholly evil results. Happily the majority of us have learned that the presence of other faiths is and should be no bar to the commonwealth that includes them all, thus creating another form of the true union of the diverse.

For no country in the world is that lesson more essential than for the United States of America. The great motto--e pluribus unum— figures on our coins and national seal. We began as a union of newly independent states diverse in character. We fought a bitter war between the States and the union was saved, though the wounds of that disastrous division are not wholly healed a century later. We admitted to our shores aspiring new groups from practically all the peoples of the earth.

We have grown to greatness as the most cosmopolitan of all nations. We are proud of the way they helped to people a continent, to break in the prairie, to overcome the wilderness, to lay railroads across the mountains, to build our cities. Yet we are all familiar with the reverses and setbacks which have occurred. We are mindful that much remains to be accomplished in bringing about real and lasting unity from our richly varied diversity.

And lest we forget—unity can only be brought about if it exists in the hearts and minds of people and if all are accorded equal rights and opportunities. It is said in our Constitution that everyone is entitled to the equal protection of the laws. We have the inscription on our Supreme Court Building in Washington "Equal Justice Under Law." We venerate the words that "all men are created equal." These are inspiring phrases; yet as mere abstractions they mean nothing, absolutely nothing.

We must give them life and content by our day-to-day relationships with each other and we must remember in a society such as ours that whatever injures one injures everyone. I would like to leave you with this thought. Over 2,500 years ago, someone asked Solon, the Athenian sage and lawgiver, how justice could be achieved in Athens. His reply, in substance, was that justice could be realized whenever those who were not injured by injustice were as outraged as those who had been.

That is as true in this day and age as it was in ancient Greece. And it is just as true between nations as it is true between men. It is our high privilege as well as our solemn responsibility to keep this sentiment alive in our nation and throughout the world. You young people have been trained in an enlightened atmosphere, and have had close and meaningful contact with other peoples of the world. I can think of no group better equipped than you to vitalize Solon's immortal principle.

I hope that none of you will ever be the victims of injustice but that you will always be as outraged by injustice as those who have been injured by it. This will make life more meaningful for you and for your entire generation;"

署名Earl Warren  1964-06-14  published in Stanford University, Stanford, California