Dean, faculty, parents, and hello, my new colleagues. Look at you. Welcome to the next phase of your life. It’s going to be amazing. There’s a war in this country over facts and truth, and it’s not clear how it’s going to play out. Congratulations: you’re heading to the front lines. I know those are words every parent wants to hear. Speaking for everyone else who’s been slogging away in the trenches: glad to have you. We need the reinforcements. Couldn’t be a better time to become a journalist.
I’m honored to be here and to be offered an award that’s also gone to so many journalists I’ve admired. It’s funny to me that you had Maggie Haberman here yesterday as your other graduation speaker, since she and I represent such radically different approaches to this job. I like imagining a version of the world where this ceremony were a little more like the Grammys and she and I would hate each other’s guts, snipe at each other on Twitter, and snatch each other’s awards like dueling, nerdy Kanyes.
I am very aware that in my twenties I got interested in doing stories about regular people and their lives precisely because I had no idea how to do what she does and what normal reporters do. I didn’t know how to cultivate sources, cover the news, or unearth important things the public needs to know. Maggie Haberman shows us all, day after day, a rigorous demonstration of how you use the traditional tools of journalism to get inside information from suspicious sources, break news, and answer the biggest questions in the most important ongoing story out there right now.
And as for me, there’s this thing the drummer for the Who once said that I relate to a lot. His name was Keith Moon. When he tried to explain what he did for a living, he once said, “I am the greatest Keith-Moon-type drummer in the world.”
I make my living with a weird grab bag of skills that probably shouldn’t add up to anything. My primary skill is that I’m a good editor. That’s the main thing I do all week. From the start, it was the one thing in journalism I had a natural talent for and an easy command of. I also have a bunch of showbizzy skills that go into packaging material into a program—pacing, flow, humor, and emotional arcs. It’s stuff I learned basically in high school musicals and as a teenaged magician at children’s birthday parties.
In my twenties there was a feeling I got in a certain kind of recorded interview that I became transfixed with, loved, and tried to make happen again and again. There’s a feeling I got when music hit underneath a radio story that just got to me. It still does, and I cultivated that. I’m also good at running and promoting a business. I like spreadsheets and budgets and dealing with member stations and all the machinery of making a radio show.
I enjoy selling, which is fortunate because a certain amount of my job is selling: on the pledge drive, in promos, and during the radio show when I’m saying things to bait people to “stay with us.” I guess the lesson for you is that there are lots of ways to be a journalist: Maggie’s way, my way. That’s good news as each of you discovers your own way.
Before I go further, I want to acknowledge my co-workers, in particular Julie Snyder, who ran This American Life with me as my partner in making the show for two decades. She left that job to create the podcasts Serial and S-Town, which—I think I can be braggy on her behalf—made the world rethink what podcasting can be.
The kind of journalism we do at our shows is a team sport. Most weeks I spend most of my hours at work not working on my own stories but in a scrum of people puzzling out how to make somebody else’s work the very best it can be. We edit each story over and over, each time dragging in someone new who hasn’t heard it yet to bring fresh ears. Our show is made as a collaboration, to serve our pleasure and curiosity as a group.
It’s best when one or more of us gets obsessed and excited about something and pulls the rest along to figure out something original to say about Afrofuturism, police violence, Iraq, post-Katrina New Orleans, or whatever. Together we set the editorial agenda and chew over which stories to pursue and what the angles should be.
In the interest of factual accuracy, I’ll say that the majority of the stories on the program that have gotten the most attention—Harper High School, “The Giant Pool of Money,” convicted murderers putting on Hamlet in prison, Nikole Hannah-Jones’s stories on our show, Sarah Koenig’s stories, Chana Joffe-Walt’s stories—were not my idea or my doing. In fact, there are not one but two stories that I was completely against us taking on that went on to win Peabody Awards. With that in mind, I accept this fancy honor on behalf of everyone I work with.
A brief digression about editing—brief but urgent. Editing does not get the respect it should. There are so many awards for reporters. Where are the awards for editors? There are so many famous reporters and so few famous editors. I believe gifted editors are rarer than talented reporters. If you have a knack for it, go for it. I really want to nudge you in that direction. It’s a wonderful job, and journalism needs you.
Editing is crucial because, in my experience, anything you try to make—what you want is for the story to be amazing. But what the story wants to be is mediocre or worse. The entire process of making the story is convincing it not to be what it wants to be, which is bad. You turn it from the bad thing it’s trying to be, where the sources are inarticulate, you don’t know how to structure it, and the structure you make doesn’t work, into the shining, gleaming jewel you have in your heart. That is editing.
Everyone else: love your editors. Choose them with the care you’d choose someone to have sex with. Do not have sex with them! Let me go back. Choose them with the care you’d choose a good friend.
Choose your jobs with a careful eye on who your editor will be. The good news is that very few editors, in my experience, are awful. The overwhelming majority are solid, decent, and helpful. And if you’re lucky, you get somebody like the people I work with, like Julie Snyder—people who make everything they touch so much better.
I’m guessing some of you are focused and directed and know exactly what you want to do. But I bet many of you are like I was all through my twenties, when I struggled to figure out how to do work that was meaningful to me. The work I do now came from that long experience of being lost and trying to invent something that made sense to me, seemed special to me, and was something I was actually good at.
So if, in the coming months and years, you feel lost and stuck in some job that isn’t what you want, I want to say to you and your parents: that’s normal. You’re not crazy. It happens to lots of us. You have to get in there, make stuff, try things, and push yourself hard. That’s the only way to find your way.
For those who feel their work still isn’t at the level they want, I can offer this: I started at NPR when I was nineteen and was not a decent writer or reporter until a decade into it. Editing I could always do, but those other skills were hard-fought and didn’t come easily. I was thirty-six when I started This American Life, seventeen years into doing this.
We’ve always had a paid internship at This American Life. It became so competitive that we had to stop calling it an internship and now call it a fellowship. One intern came from a reporting job at NBC News; another came from the digital staff of The New York Times. At some point I looked at the candidates’ skills and realized that if I’d applied at any point in my twenties, I wouldn’t have gotten it. I couldn’t have been an intern on my own show. It can take a long time to be as good as you want to be. Be kind to yourself during that period, and work hard.
You all are entering journalism at a fascinating and intense time. For starters, I don’t know if you’ve heard: everyone in the country hates everyone else all the time. Doing fact-based stories in that environment has some challenges.
Two weeks ago, we were lucky to work with Steve Kolowich of The Chronicle of Higher Education on something that happened at the University of Nebraska. A sophomore put out a table to start a chapter of Turning Point USA, a right-wing group, on campus. A left-wing teacher and graduate student in her forties yelled at the girl and called her names until the sophomore was in tears. Video went online, things exploded, the legislature got involved, and everyone assumed the worst of everyone else at nearly every moment.
Steve and his producer Dana Chivvis did a careful, sympathetic, evenhanded job parsing everyone’s motives and what we should make of it. But because we talked to the right-wing student to hear her side, one listener wrote, “I don’t even want to listen to this bullshit. I’m so sick of This American Life highlighting the right. You don’t have to give equal airtime to stupidity just because stupidity took the office.” Another wrote, “Thanks for giving voice to a fascist organization. I’m out.”
Another wrote, “So many pieces about how we ‘elite’ liberals just don’t understand conservatives.” That was not what the story was about, by the way. The fact someone took it that way is so dispiriting. The listener continued: “I understand them just fine. They’re usually racist, don’t ‘believe’ in science or facts. I’ve had enough of these ‘but what about the poor conservatives?’ pieces.” Another said, “Honestly, I’m getting a little tired of This American Life’s fixation on conservatives. I really have no interest in them or their feelings.”
This intolerance even to listen to someone else is new among our audience. Three or four years ago, we never got this reaction. Reading the comments, one co-worker says it freaks him out because he feels people don’t understand what journalism is. Sending some of our stories into this environment is like throwing baby bunnies into a cage of hungry snakes. Do we really expect the snakes not to lick their lips and eat the bunnies?
The good news is that most listeners were not like the ones I’m quoting. That was a tiny percentage of the comments. Lots of people seem okay with how we’re doing this coverage.
Last night I did a fundraiser for a public radio station in someone’s very nice suburban home. The host told me she’d heard our episode on Republican Senator Jeff Flake. Producer Zoe Chace followed him for four months as he tried to get DACA legislation passed. The host described her feeling as, “No. Don’t make me like him! I didn’t want it to happen, but you humanized him.” I said, “We didn’t humanize him. He is a human!”
We simply documented who he is, as we document anyone else. Zoe presented his stubborn idealism and his flaws, argued with his premises, and challenged him point by point throughout the hour—the same way we do with anyone on the show. The listener seemed cautiously okay with seeing him as a human being: a person she didn’t agree with, but a person with principles and decency, not a monster.
That journalism can do this is one thing it can accomplish now. I don’t think anyone changes their mind about DACA or any other issue because of a radio story. That’s not how people work. You wouldn’t change your mind about abortion, guns, or whom to vote for based on a radio story. But in this utterly divided moment, I think it’s possible to get listeners to understand the reality and complexity of people outside their particular group, whatever that group may be.
We do many stories on refugees and immigrants. We’ve done stories on kids in neighborhoods where friends have been shot and they fear being shot. We did an hour with women in an office talking, among other things, about how a sexually harassing boss messed with their minds and feelings. I don’t think we changed anyone’s mind on those issues. But those stories made clear the stakes of those experiences. In some crude way, they did the old-fashioned thing a story is supposed to do: make it possible to imagine, if this happened to you, what it might feel like.
I want to be clear: empathy is not enough in reporting. There are lots of people I do not empathize with. After Charlottesville, our staff genuinely disagreed about putting certain white nationalists on the air and whether doing so promoted their ideas, no matter how we framed it.
With respect to those who feel differently, I believe you can put someone like that on the air and interrogate them the way we interrogate anyone and anything else. In that case, we could ask the rally organizer what he was trying to do and how he felt about the results. When someone died, was he glad? Sorry? Guilty? That seemed worth knowing. Some stories are not about empathy but about investigating a phenomenon to understand what we’re really dealing with.
Another thing I think about constantly is that there are all sorts of stories nobody wants to hear any more about. Refugee coverage is a perfect example because it has the two key ingredients of any such story: first, it’s depressing; second, you already know it. Sixty million displaced people, the largest refugee crisis since World War II. Middle-class people from Syria and elsewhere whose homes were bombed out of existence, with nowhere to go. Europe and America don’t want them. People die on boats and live in camps. The audience thinks, “We’ve got it. What else would I ever need to know?”
There are many other stories in this category: climate change, almost anything about the environment, many human-rights stories, social-justice stories, and criminal-justice stories. These issues are important to cover, but it is very hard to get anybody to listen. We still do those stories, and they require cunning. When you do them, that should be part of what you think about. I believe the more idealistic your mission, the more cunning you must employ to get people to engage with what you have to say.
We did two hours from refugee camps in Greece. We knew that if we said at the top, “Great, America! Two hours from refugee camps in Greece!” any reasonable person would turn off the radio because it was too sad. Being cunning means getting hardcore about how you begin such stories—how you pull people in and get them listening. This may sound terrible, but our goal is to pull them in before they understand what the story is about.
Before we went to Greece, a group of us brainstormed how we could begin those shows. Maybe a couple falling in love; maybe something with kids; basically any little narrative with someone fun to hear. We could get the characters going and let plot kick in, so the audience became invested in the people and wanted to know how it would play out. This is one of narrative’s great strengths for a journalist: you can get audiences to hear material they think they don’t care about by getting them caught up in the people and wondering what happens next.
The thing we actually started with happened while I was reporting in a camp called Ritsona. People showing me around would mention, “Oh yeah, and then there are the wild boars that come out at night.” I said, “The wild boars that come out at night?” They were giant wild pigs. The camp was in a forest, and the boars roamed between the tents at night. If a little kid needed to pee, it was dangerous to leave the tent. You had to time it around the pigs.
Everybody had pictures and stories about the pigs. One older man had set up a trap in the woods that was not going to work at all, and I made him take me out and show it to me. I thought, “This is so surprising. This can open the show.” You’ve got to be tricky.
Something came up in a story we did that I’ve been thinking about for months. Our senior producer Brian Reed, who also hosts S-Town, reported on a political fight in Homer, Alaska, about immigration, right after the presidential election. Liberals on the city council proposed a resolution welcoming immigrants to Homer, including undocumented immigrants and Muslims. Trump supporters rightly recognized it as a slap against their guy.
As Brian reported, it became the bitterest political fight anyone in town could remember. It turned people against one another in an ugly way, led to a recall election, and produced their own email scandal. Everyone took a side except, apparently, a twenty-seven-year-old named Ben Tyrer. He wasn’t into news and had never followed immigration, but now everyone he knew was fighting over this resolution, so he thought he should have an opinion.
Ben went online and began visiting news sites to decide whether it would be okay to welcome immigrants to Homer. When it came to news, he told Brian, he was basically a baby learning to walk. He understood that The New York Times and The Washington Post had a bad rap, so he didn’t spend much time there. He tried the BBC but worried about a liberal bent. Then he tried a conservative Canadian site, The Rebel, but knew he couldn’t fully trust it either.
This is a good test case for journalism today: someone who doesn’t follow news goes out among the work of people like us looking for a straightforward answer and discovers that, in today’s environment, he doesn’t know whom to trust. The experience was head-spinning.
Ben read that Muslim extremists had set fire to Germany’s oldest church and watched a video of them celebrating. He read about “no-go zones” in France, where Muslims supposedly don’t allow non-Muslims. He read about crime waves sweeping Germany and France because of Muslim refugees. One Breitbart article quoted a German government report saying 402,000 crimes were committed by Muslim refugees in Germany in 2015.
After a week, Ben concluded that welcoming immigrants to Homer would be unsafe. Immigrants, especially Muslims, seemed dangerous. He was so alarmed that he testified at a large city-council meeting, bringing his news clippings. Then the story took a surprising turn. As Brian left one interview, Ben said, “I’d love for you to tell me that I’m wrong. If you can read this stuff and tell me I’m wrong, I would love that, because I don’t like thinking this way about people.”
Brian found an expert to fact-check the stories: a BBC correspondent in Berlin who had covered the subject for years. The BBC was one source Ben distrusted, but he was willing to listen. The reporter investigated all the stories Ben had found convincing, and Brian arranged for them to talk.
A couple of the alarming stories were true, but most were exaggerated or totally false. No-go zones in France do not exist. There was no increase in crime by immigrants in Germany in 2015, except border crossing or visa overstays. The Breitbart video supposedly showing Muslim men celebrating after burning Germany’s oldest church? The church was not Germany’s oldest and had not been set on fire. The men were Syrian refugees celebrating a ceasefire back home.
Ben was flabbergasted. He felt deceived and concluded he had been wrong about the whole thing. Immigrants no longer seemed dangerous. I bring this up because none of the news stories Ben found so convincing were stories I had ever heard of.
It had never hit me so starkly. We all know there’s a massive machine churning out non-factual stories that the fact-based media where I work doesn’t even bother to counter, because there are so many. They simply stand uncorrected. Even if they were corrected, people who trust those right-wing sources do not trust the mainstream sources that would correct them.
I am alarmed by how much non-factual material is out there, how gleefully it is generated, and how exciting it is to read and pass around. I’m disturbed by how often, while reporting, I meet lovely, good people who say things that are nowhere close to true. That is what I find most alarming about this moment.
President Trump, like President Obama, will be out of the White House someday. As a nonpartisan journalist, I have no position on that. But this information ecosystem will probably be around for the rest of our lives. That’s the most frightening thing to me. Non-factual information whips up people’s feelings and pushes policy debate to strange places—like Homer, Alaska, where everyone was fighting over whether to welcome immigrants.
But immigrants do not want to go to Homer, Alaska! The police chief told us, “Homer is not a destination for immigrants, illegal or legal, and it never has been.” Imagine you want to enter the United States undocumented from Central America. You pass through Mexico, cross into California or Texas, traverse the whole United States, enter Canada, cross Canada, reenter the United States at Alaska, and travel to the end of the peninsula. It is the furthest point on the road.
Or you’re a member of ISIS fleeing Syria. Where do you go? The United States! New York City? No. Chicago? No. Homer, Alaska! Fly to Homer. You will not be conspicuous in any way. You will hate the food.
The people pushing untruths see this as a war. They talk about it and fund it like a war, on the theory that, as Andrew Breitbart declared, “Politics is downstream from culture.” To change the country’s politics, you first change the culture. Most of the fact-based news media—our people—do not treat it like a war. I think we need to.
We need to flood the zone with money and new ideas about how to reach people and what to reach them with. This moment requires a strategy not yet invented by people who have yet to take up arms. When one side fights a war against an opponent who isn’t fighting, guess who loses territory? We have lost a lot. Large parts of the country do not trust us, and we have a president who calls our work “fake news.”
We need your ideas and energy to fight this war. And we need great reporting. One hopeful thing is watching so many organizations rise to the occasion with inspiringly excellent reporting, day after day. But there is plenty of room for more. We are living through a moment of seismic, historic change. You bring fresh eyes and a perspective those of us who are older do not have.
It’s traditional in this sort of speech to give advice. I will not do that. Except this: amuse yourself. I don’t think enough is said about that when we train journalists. Everything will be better if you’re out for your own pleasure—if you notice what truly interests you and makes you curious and make your work about that.
Our radio show is run on the principle that, among other things, it exists for our pleasure, fun, and curiosity as a staff. It is at its best when one of us gets obsessed. Even when I was a baby freelancer taking any story NPR threw my way, I had a rule: every story needed something just for me—an observation that amused me, a funny line, or an interesting back-and-forth on tape.
For those doing broadcast or podcast: be in the tape! Cajole, hondle, joke with, argue with, and interact with your interviewees. It is the single easiest way to improve your stories. An interview properly done is a drama with two characters. If you are not there as one of them, you’re giving up one of your greatest powers. Don’t leave that power unused. Be in the tape. Don’t settle for less or do less than you can.
If you’re funny in real life, be funny in your stories. It makes them better and doesn’t mean you aren’t a serious person dealing with serious subjects in a serious way. If you’re not funny in real life, for God’s sake don’t try to be funny. Be yourself.
Don’t wait. Make the stuff you want to make now. No excuses. Don’t wait for the perfect job. Don’t wait, don’t wait, don’t wait. One advantage of being a journalist is that you don’t need permission. You can run down the story now and find a home for it later. Pay someone you respect—a friend—a little money to be your editor and discuss your next steps. Pay in food if you like. You have everything you need right now. Don’t wait.
Commencement addresses are a ridiculous form. They are doomed to failure because nothing can be said that is equal to the task. You are being launched from the training phase of your life into the vast, exciting unknown of everything to come. What words could make that better? Seriously, what poncy little speech makes a rocket’s liftoff any better? Your ambition and hopes for your coming lives are enough to fill this day with feeling and meaning. The wishes of your parents and loved ones are enough.
To those, I add my own wishes, which are big. I want you to be bold. I want you to change things. Although I am what came before you, I want you to tear up what came before you. I really, truly, no kidding, envy you: starting as journalists today, at a moment when journalism itself is changing so much; being part of remaking it into something new; reporting on these difficult, historic times; battling untruth with truth.
Best to you all, my new colleagues.