Dean Baquet's 2016 Class Day Keynote Address at Columbia College: Don't Let Ambition Blind You

Dean Baquet's 2016 Class Day Keynote Address at Columbia College: Don't Let Ambition Blind You

5/17/2016South Lawns, Columbia University, New York City

Speech Audio

0:00
16:35

Speech Videos

Source: YouTubeVideo copyright belongs to original author

Content

· 2,465 words
20
Background: Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and then New York Times executive editor Dean Baquet addressed Columbia College's Class Day on May 17, 2016. He begins with his upbringing in a working-class Black neighborhood of New Orleans and recalls arriving at Columbia at seventeen, aimless and afraid, before the campus gradually widened his understanding of the world. Stories from his early police and court reporting illustrate the value of listening, humility, fairness, and empathy, including mistakes that taught him how ambition can distort judgment. Baquet urges graduates not to let ambition obscure the journey, hurt the people around them, or force them to compromise their principles. He closes with an account of publishing an investigative Los Angeles Times story despite pressure from the CIA, underscoring independent judgment and professional ethics in the face of power. This edition was prepared from the automatic captions on the alumni association's video and editorially reviewed.

I think if I had known graduation was this much fun, I might have actually stuck around and graduated. Don't tell my mom. I can't tell you how much it means to me to be back here as your speaker. I give many talks around the country, but mostly they're about journalism, the threats against it, and how important it is to society.

What I rarely do is reflect on my own life. It feels narcissistic to me. I think journalists choose the profession because it allows them to examine others, to question the powerful, to criticize society. We don't much like to think about our own lives. We are not what you would call self-reflective. So thinking of what to say to you was actually quite hard.

It meant digging back in time and thinking about my own life, searching for any lessons, any guidance I could give people who are about to embark on their own adventures, who will have families, struggle through wildly successful and occasionally unsatisfying careers. And as I thought through it all, I realized there might be some lessons embedded in my life.

The word “aimless” does not quite capture the seventeen-year-old kid who left New Orleans forty-two years ago for Morningside Heights. Maybe “aimless and scared” works best in combination. I grew up in a household of no books, to parents who did not graduate from high school. I'd never been on an airplane. I had spent my whole life in working-class, old Black neighborhoods, where the only white people around me were nuns and priests. I thought of them as “the other,” and that they had no race, no history, no real background that I knew of or cared about.

I actually had no luggage, though I had a lot of baggage. And I did not even own an overcoat when I accepted a scholarship to Columbia. I had only applied because a close friend of mine had always wanted to go there, and he wanted company. I had barely heard of Columbia. Unfortunately, I got in and he did not. Now, it's not tragic; he got in later on. Don't worry.

I grew up in a neighborhood called Tremé, famous then and now for its jazz musicians, public dancing, and crime. I don't ever recall being outside of Tremé except for the times my father drove to the French Quarter to buy cigarettes from a vending machine in a bar. My New Orleans, much like the New Orleans of today, much like most big American cities, was segregated by race and economics.

It is odd that I became executive editor of The New York Times, given that as a kid I never heard of The New York Times, unlike most of the people I work with today, who seem to build their lives around a desire to work for what was then, and still is, the world's greatest newspaper. One of the themes of my editorship, by the way, is that I want to make sure it doesn't become so expensive and so exclusive that it turns off people like the kid I was.

I had a father who wanted for us to succeed, and he was a constant and forceful presence. I don't recall feeling this at the time, but his insistence that we mop the bar before school every day instilled in me the foundation of a work ethic. It has taken years, and reading much literature, poetry, and history, to understand that his anger and exhaustion came from growing up in the segregated South, with the limitations that had been forced on his own ambitions.

A side lesson, if you'll indulge me: your parents may actually be better than you think they are. Just take a bit of time to see the world through their eyes, and trust me, it is worth the exercise. My father could be hard to live with sometimes, but he gave us a sense that we could succeed, though what success meant in a world that seemed relatively small was elusive. Somewhere in there I developed a relentless ambition that has pushed me, sometimes pained me, to this day. I will talk later about that ambition and the importance of tempering it.

Here is a memory from my first exposure to politicians, one that I realize affected me a great deal, since I have now spent most of my life either covering politicians or directing coverage of them, from George Bush the first to Donald Trump the first. My first exposure to a Louisiana politician was the day Governor John McKeithen, well into his second term, came to our new gymnasium at St. Augustine High School in New Orleans.

There was a sense that this was a big deal: a governor making his way to our little school to talk to us as future leaders. I have a vague recollection that McKeithen was regarded, by Southern standards, as relatively progressive. But what I remember most is that his deep, deep Louisiana accent caused him to mangle the word “Negro” in an embarrassing way that left all seven hundred of us feeling humiliated and angry, and a little sad that we couldn't do anything about it. We were called together the next day and told that it was a mispronunciation. I'm not sure I believed it.

That was the scared kid who showed up at Columbia, a little baffled that you could fit a whole school in such a tight space and that the greenery around College Walk was not nearly as huge as the recruiting catalogues made it appear. My college grades were not particularly great, but something happened to me at Columbia that I'm not even sure I understood at the time. Quietly, slowly, my world expanded: the exposure to people, the understanding that the world was wider, that there was art, and that most of your education took place not in the classroom.

I think it was at Columbia that I learned two valuable lessons that have stayed with me and that I'd like to stay with you: listen, and listen hard. And while you shouldn't question your own ethics, you should question your own certainty about everything else. This is the advice part of the speech, for what it's worth—what I learned at Columbia and after. I hope you hear at least part of it and grapple with it in your own lives, because I have no doubt, despite my warning about certainty, that that's the truth.

Don't let ambition blind you. Don't have your eyes so focused on the goal—whether it be money or rank or some other measure of success—that you fail to enjoy the journey getting there. Don't be so ambitious for one thing that you fail to see when something better comes along, something more fulfilling, something that stirs your soul more powerfully. And don't let ambition warp your sense of self or force you to compromise your principles.

Pay attention when others—your family, your colleagues, everyone you encounter—say that your drive is causing them pain, because they're probably right. I vaguely thought I wanted to be a lawyer or maybe a professor. Then I walked into a newsroom for the first time. I just wanted a job, but I found a calling. It was a hot day in New Orleans. I heard the clattering of typewriters—you can see them in a museum sometime. I saw people rushing around on deadline, people hunched over their desks, half doing interviews over the phone, shouting at each other, and I fell in love.

Suddenly this young man who was a little listless, with scattered but intense reading habits, getting B's and C's, was working long hours, not even punching in for overtime. I did the grunt work, covering fires and murders. The first time I saw a bloated dead body pulled out of the Mississippi River, I turned away and threw up while the cops laughed at me. I listened as mothers told the stories of the lives of sons who had been killed or had killed, and I came to understand that literally everyone has a story if you just shut up and listen.

Remember what I said about enjoying the journey. Looking back, someone told me that I should never be a journalist because I would end up covering cops and courts, and wouldn't that be awful? Truth be told, covering cops and courts was the absolute most fun I've ever had in my professional life. During those months I grabbed hold of everyone who could teach me anything, and I forced myself on them.

One reporter who was ignored by all of his colleagues because he was a little eccentric taught me that if you smile and show some humility, people will invite you into their houses and tell you their stories. They just want to tell them to someone who will honestly listen, who won't greedily exploit their tragedy. When I ran out of teachers, I grabbed newspapers from the library and deconstructed the way stories were put together, and copied until I could do it myself.

I learned fairness by being totally unfair. One day, while covering a rape trial, I wrote a hyped and exaggerated story about the defendant just so I could make the front page. I was shameless, overeager, too ambitious—and I was proud of myself. Front-page stories were hard to come by for a beginning reporter who was now all of twenty years old. I was pleased with myself, that is until I walked into court the next day and was confronted by the defendant, an indignant man who deserved a lot better than an ambitious careerist trying to make a name for himself.

He glowered at me the whole day until I shrank in the back of the courtroom. Then his lawyer chewed me out, and I learned a valuable lesson about fairness, one that I've never forgotten. I had misdirected my ambition and abused my power, meager as it was, and never did it again.

I had a friend and colleague who was truly an empathetic person. He and I once went to the home of the mother of a crime victim, desperate for an interview. Ambitiously, I rushed toward the door, the hunt for a good quote practically dripping from me. He walked in listening, shuffling slightly, wanting to hear her story. She talked to him. She barely noticed me.

In the years since, I've worked for five newspapers, counting two times at The New York Times. I've stumbled, almost literally, into a profession that has taken me around the world, that has let me ask tough questions of the most powerful people in the world, but has also left me mumbling incoherently at lunch with Gabriel García Márquez. I've had a blast. And no one believes this, but I've never thought for one second about the end game. I never fantasized about being editor of the New Orleans Times-Picayune, let alone The New York Times. I had a blast with the doing.

In fact, I've always had suspicions about colleagues who seem overly ambitious, who seem driven by something else. There is, of course, a contradiction here. Of course I was ambitious, but maybe my upbringing left me able to enjoy the doing without expectations for something too great.

One last story about sticking to your principles. When I was managing editor of the Los Angeles Times, shortly after 9/11, my phone rang one morning as I had coffee in the house in Santa Monica. On the line, to my surprise, was George Tenet, then the director of the Central Intelligence Agency. Tenet is a charming man. We made small talk. I told him I was planning on taking my son to a movie and I couldn't make up my mind between a family film and a war movie. He recommended the war movie. “Boys like that kind of stuff,” Tenet said, summoning, I suppose, years of intelligence experience.

Then he got to the point. The Los Angeles Times was about to publish a fairly explosive story about how the CIA was spying on the Iranian community in the United States as a way to learn more about Iran, where it had precious few spies. This story, Tenet insisted, seriously would endanger lives. It would hurt an ongoing intelligence operation. Then he added darkly: it would hurt the war on terrorism. I told him he had to be more specific, that my job was to publish stories, not to kill them. He couldn't tell me more, just that it would hurt the war on terrorism and I should be a patriot.

I agreed to hold the story for one day so I could at least have another look at it and talk to the writer. Then I took my son to see the family movie. I thought about it hard, but I thought that my principle—that the world had the right to know how the government spies on it—trumped Tenet's principle. The next day I called Tenet at home, told him I hadn't heard enough of a reason to hold the story, and that we were publishing it the next day on the front page under our banner headline, which we did.

The day of publication I waited for the world to cave in, for the government to denounce us, at least for Bill O'Reilly to call me unpatriotic. I was disappointed. Nothing happened, not a thing. To put it mildly, the head of the CIA had exaggerated, to say the least. Here's how editors have fun. I walked into the newsroom the next day after publication and watched as every other newspaper in America picked up our story, giving us credit. Actually, I strutted through the newsroom that day, taking calls here and there from editors at competing papers. Editors have fun.

By God, I'd like to thank you for the chance to speak to you today. If you keep your ambition in check and enjoy the doing, not just the getting there, you will have a better time in whatever you do. You should listen and never assume you're right. You've given me a chance to honor a school that has given me the courage and confidence to get to places I would never have gone, and to remind myself just how much fun I've had along the way. And I thank you sincerely.

journalismethicsClass DayColumbia Universityambitionlistening

About the Speaker

View details→
D

Dean Baquet

American journalist, editor, and Pulitzer Prize winner

Birth:1956Country:United States

Dean Baquet is an American journalist and newspaper editor born in New Orleans's Tremé neighborhood in 1956. He studied at Columbia University from 1974 to 1978 and began his career covering police and crime for the Times-Picayune. At the Chicago Tribune, he helped expose corruption in the Chicago City Council and won the 1988 Pulitzer Prize for Investigative Reporting. He later served as editor of the Los Angeles Times, Washington bureau chief and managing editor of The New York Times, and from 2014 to 2022 became the Times's first Black executive editor. His tenure emphasized digital growth, investigative reporting, and newsroom diversity. After stepping down, he continued supporting public-interest reporting by leading a fellowship focused on local investigative journalism.

「Listen, and listen hard.」

← Back to Speeches