Alibaba's Ma Reflects On 12-Year Journey at China 2.0 Conference

Alibaba's Ma Reflects On 12-Year Journey at China 2.0 Conference

10/6/2011Stanford University, California, United States

Speech Audio

0:00
56:47

Speech Videos

Source: YouTubeVideo copyright belongs to original author

Content

· 5,325 words
20
Background: Jack Ma delivered the closing keynote at Stanford's China 2.0 conference on September 30, 2011, and Stanford Graduate School of Business published the full recording on October 6. He reviewed Alibaba's twelve-year journey and discussed B2B, Taobao, Alipay, AliCloud, small businesses, credit systems, and corporate responsibility. Roughly thirty-five minutes of questions followed, covering a possible Yahoo acquisition, VIE regulation, lessons from Yahoo China, Taobao's structure and logistics, the Alipay dispute, international access, foreign companies in China, U.S.-China misunderstandings, and globalization. This edited transcript follows the publisher-provided English captions, preserves all speakers and question order, removes nonverbal markers and empty disfluencies, and corrects clear contextual errors in names, figures, and technical terms.

Moderator: It is a great pleasure for us to give a warm welcome to Jack Ma. Thank you.

Jack Ma: It is my great honor. I was invited months ago, and I did not expect people to say that this was a very sensitive time for me to speak, because of Yahoo, Alibaba, and everything else. But a promise is a promise, so I came. Today, I will answer any questions you have.

I have been here for fifteen days, and I plan to spend one year here. Nobody knew—not even my company—that I was going to spend a year here. People asked, “Why are you here? Are you getting ready to acquire Yahoo?” No. Everybody became very sensitive when I said I would spend a year here. I am here because I am tired.

I have been working for the past sixteen years. In 1994, I discovered the internet, became fascinated by it, and gave up my teaching job. I was like a blind man riding on the back of a blind tiger, jumping around, still kicking, and somehow surviving. I then worked in a government organization for sixteen months. That did not succeed, so I started Alibaba in 1999.

We built Alibaba, and we were lucky enough to create Taobao, Alipay, AliCloud, and many other things. After twelve years, I said that I needed time to rest. This year in particular has been very difficult for me.

At the beginning of the year, our Alibaba.com CEO resigned because of supplier fraud. Then there was the Alipay issue and all the discussion about VIEs—I still do not really know what a VIE is. We also split Taobao into four parts. So many things made me feel tired.

I thought, why not take one year off? Next year is my zodiac year, and it could be even more difficult. This year was tough; I believe next year will be tougher and more complicated, so I want to be ready. I need a rest in order to think about the next three or four years.

For the next three years, daily operations are not my job. If something goes wrong, criticize the presidents and CEOs of Taobao, Alibaba.com, and Alipay—it is their fault. If something goes wrong three years from now, it will be my fault. I came to the United States to think, relax, play a little golf, and rest. It is not for the reasons people imagine.

We are a very lucky company. There was almost no reason for us to survive. I did not have a special background, a rich father, or powerful uncles.

In 1999, I came to Silicon Valley looking for venture capital. I spoke to many venture capitalists and was rejected by almost all of them. When I talked about an Alibaba startup, they looked at me strangely and asked, “Alibaba? What are you talking about?” I went back to China with no money and no investment, but full of confidence because I had seen the American dream.

In 1999, I saw highways crowded with cars every evening and office parks full of people working day and night, even on weekends. I believed the same thing would happen in China. I returned without venture capital, but with the American dream. We started the business, and a great deal happened over the next twelve years.

We built a B2B business when nobody believed it would work. Famous American B2B companies focused on big companies and buyers. We believed China did not have many big private companies. The big companies were mostly state-owned enterprises, and they did not need e-commerce as much as they needed government policy. So we focused on small businesses and the private sector, because we believed they were China’s future.

American B2B companies tried to help buyers save time and cost. We thought there was no need to teach small businesses how to save money; they knew that better than we did. We should help them make money. We focused on helping small businesses find customers and sell abroad.

It was very difficult at first, but after twelve years more than 58 million small businesses around the world were using our services. The model was not very sexy, and we did not make as much money as online-gaming companies. But we could sleep well, because our money came from helping small businesses survive and find opportunities. I am proud of that impact, not of how much money we make.

Before the internet, no company could help more than 50 million small and medium-sized enterprises. We are trying to do that. People once told me that making Alibaba successful would be like pulling a million-ton ship to the top of the Himalayas. I said, “Yes, and we will carry it back down.” We did.

The second company was Taobao. Everybody said, “My God, you are competing with eBay.” I said, “Why not?” China needed an e-commerce marketplace, and building that market required time and effort. If you never try, how do you know there is no chance?

We said that if eBay was a shark in the ocean, we were a crocodile in the Yangtze River. We would not fight in the ocean; we would fight in the river. It was difficult, but it was also a lot of fun, and we survived. eBay had about 90 percent of the market then; today, fortunately, we have about 90 percent. We were lucky.

People always write about Alibaba’s success, but I do not think we were so smart. We made many mistakes and did many stupid things. Someday I want to write a book called Alibaba’s 1,001 Mistakes. Those are the things people should remember and learn from.

It is hard to learn how other people succeeded, because success contains so much luck. But if you learn how people fail, you will benefit a lot. I like reading books about failure. If you examine failed companies, you find that the reasons for failure are often very similar. That is what really matters.

After Taobao came Alipay. Everybody said China had no credit system, terrible banking, and terrible logistics, so e-commerce could not work. But precisely because China lacked good logistics, credit, and banking systems, we needed entrepreneurship. We needed to build them, and what we built could later become a standard for China.

Six years ago, I told an American audience that within five years China would have more internet users than the United States. People said no. I said, “You have only 300 million people. For you to have 400 million internet users without anyone dying and while waiting for babies to grow up would take fifty years. We need only five.” It was simply a matter of time, and today China has more users.

People now say Chinese consumers have low purchasing power. Let us wait another five years. Today a person may spend only 200 RMB a month online; five years from now, that person may spend 2,000. We have patience. I may be old, but the average age of our people is only twenty-six. They are young, and that is why we work for the future.

Alipay began as what people called a stupid escrow service. John wanted to buy from Stephen, but John did not want to send the money first and Stephen did not want to ship the product first. We opened an account and said, “Send the money to us. If you are satisfied, we will send it to the seller. If not, return the product and we will refund the money.”

People said the model was stupid. We did not care whether it looked stupid; we cared whether customers wanted it and whether it met their needs. After seven years, more than 600 million registered users in China were using it. A stupid thing, improved every day, can become very smart. By transaction volume, Alipay was already larger than PayPal.

The last and most important business is AliCloud. Other companies talk about cloud computing because they want to sell hardware or software. We had nothing to sell. We needed to process our own data—from small businesses, Taobao consumers, and Alipay—and we believed the future would be a world of data processing. The question was how to share data with others in a responsible and useful way.

The business was not perfect, but the whole company looked healthy. We were grateful, because there had seemed to be no chance that we could win, yet we survived. We often asked ourselves why we still worked so hard.

One colleague told me, “Jack, I never knew I could accomplish so much in my life. I never knew the things I was doing could be so meaningful to society. And I never knew life could be so damn hard.” We still worked day and night. I became thinner and looked strange, but we felt proud because we were changing China. It was not about money.

Ten years ago, people stopped me on the street to thank me because Alibaba’s B2B service helped them receive orders from overseas. Today, young people say, “Jack, thank you. My wife and I opened a small shop on Taobao. It gives us a living and a good income.” That is meaningful.

We are also turning credit into value. Years ago, a good record for trust did not make you prosperous. Today, if you have a good record on Taobao, people are willing to do business with you, and that can help you succeed.

We are teaching consumers to be smart. People ask, “Jack, I bought something very cheaply on Taobao. Is it fake?” Counterfeits exist everywhere, and we devote enormous effort to intellectual-property problems. But sometimes a bottle of wine that costs nine dollars sells for three hundred because of distribution, advertising, and television. Why should consumers pay so much?

A T-shirt may cost thirty or fifteen on Taobao and one hundred fifty in a shop. That is not necessarily because Taobao is too cheap; perhaps the shop is too expensive. Consumers should learn to judge value for themselves.

We also saw many manufacturers in Guangdong that were not really complete businesses. They made products but did not know who sold for them or who their customers were. When conditions changed, they were in trouble. Manufacturers need to reach consumers, sell for themselves, and serve customers directly. Otherwise, they are only workshops. We are helping them change, and we are proud of that.

If you have one million dollars, you are rich. If you have ten million, you are in trouble because you start worrying about investment. If you have one billion, it is not really your money; it represents society’s trust. Shareholders and the public believe you can use it more wisely than others, perhaps even more wisely than government. The challenge is how to honor that trust.

Alibaba’s true product is its people—its employees and colleagues. Their average age is twenty-six, and they face enormous challenges. An official from another country once said, “You have 300 million Taobao users. That is more than the population of my country.” Any policy we make can affect huge numbers of people, almost like a government policy, yet the people making those decisions are only twenty-six on average.

For example, on a normal shopping search engine, whoever pays more may appear at the top. We believed trust and credibility records should also influence ranking. When we changed the policy, about two hundred people came to our company to protest. I said that if the change was right, we had to do it.

That is the world we are changing. We no longer need only programmers, service staff, and product managers. We also need sociologists, economists, and people who can design principles and policies. In the twenty-first century, a successful company must learn to solve social problems rather than merely catch one or two opportunities.

After twelve years, I have found that making money is relatively simple. Making money sustainably, taking responsibility for society, improving the world, and still earning a profit is very difficult. That is what we are trying to do, and the internet is helping China improve.

I am preparing for what may happen three years from now. People say Chinese internet stocks are falling because of VIEs or other reasons. Look at the American economy: it faces major challenges. Europe may be going nowhere. What happens in the United States and Europe today may happen in China three years later. China could face a serious challenge in three or four years.

If you know something bad is coming, prepare instead of screaming or complaining. Internet companies must take responsibility. I am not a politician and do not speak for the government. I speak for myself, my business, and my customers: more than 50 million SMEs and eight million Taobao sellers. How will they survive three years from now?

That is one reason I came to the United States. President Obama says he will create jobs. How does he do it? What mistakes are made, and what can we learn from them? Three years from now, we can solve similar problems in our own way. That is why I am here. Now I am ready to answer your questions. This was just a free talk. Thank you very much.

Moderator: Please line up at the microphone on this side.

Questioner 1: Mr. Ma, you brought this up first, so I will make you answer your own question honestly: are you going to buy Yahoo?

Jack Ma: Good question. Yes, we are very interested in Yahoo. Alibaba Group is important to Yahoo, and Yahoo is also very important to us, to internet users, and to the industry. Private-equity firms and other serious buyers have already talked to us, and they should talk to us more.

Questioner 1: Have you made an initial approach to Yahoo about buying it?

Jack Ma: For now, I can only assure you that we are very interested.

Questioner 2: The Chinese government has adopted a national-security review system for mergers and acquisitions of Chinese companies by foreign companies. How do you view the impact of that scrutiny? Do you think it will adversely affect Chinese companies seeking financing overseas, particularly through the VIE model?

Jack Ma: I considered answering in Chinese because this is a complicated subject, but I will try in English. So many people talk about VIEs that I became confused and spent a lot of time asking what they really are. First, I believe the VIE structure was a great innovation. Over the past ten years, it helped China’s internet and high-tech industries grow, and Alibaba benefited from it.

I do not see the government trying to abolish VIEs, and I do not know why people worry so much. But the government has understandable concerns about their use in sensitive sectors, such as finance. For example, China limits foreign ownership when granting banking licenses. If someone used a structure to evade such a national rule, we would oppose that too.

I have not heard the government say it will shut the structure down. We should make VIEs legal and transparent. The internet has the power to bring things into the open. If a model has been tested for ten years and is good, why not clarify it? If certain sensitive areas make regulators uncomfortable, they should join the discussion.

People say something went wrong with Alipay. In a way, I am honored that the case forced the VIE issue into the open. When the People’s Bank of China asked whether Alipay had foreign capital, I had to tell the truth. If I had said no when it did, that would not work, especially as the company grew larger.

If I said today that I wanted to buy PayPal, do you think the United States would have no concerns? Of course it would; the same may be true even with Yahoo. We should be fair. This is not an impossible issue. Face it, make it transparent, and discuss it. I do not believe the government intends to shut VIEs down.

Questioner 3: We have not seen each other for more than ten years, and you look terrific. You said that someday you would write a book about your mistakes. Could you share one thing that, looking back, you would do differently?

Jack Ma: Thank you, Michelle. We have gone through many tough days. When everything is smooth, I actually feel uncomfortable. In the United States, you might call that paranoia.

We made many mistakes when we acquired Yahoo China. If you ask whether I would make the acquisition again, yes. Would I do it in the same way? No. We would do it much more intelligently. We had no experience in acquisitions, especially the acquisition of an internet company. We made mistakes in integrating the culture, in deciding whom to dismiss, and in deciding whom to retain.

Those mistakes helped us. They also help us understand Yahoo in the United States. People say, “Yahoo China was terrible. How can you still talk about Yahoo?” It was not simply bad management. We recognized the problems four years ago and cut back Yahoo China; if we had not, it could have killed us. Companies in both China and the United States should learn from Yahoo’s experience and from one another’s mistakes.

Questioner 4: I have three questions. First, Taobao has been incredibly successful. How do you keep it nimble and prevent it from becoming a victim of its own scale? Second, with competitors such as 360buy, will you be forced to build your own logistics operation and change your model? Third, regarding Alipay, if you could do it again, how would you have wanted the dialogue with Masayoshi Son and Jerry Yang to go?

Jack Ma: Taobao has grown very fast and will grow even faster. We have never run a company this large. I do not believe in an internet empire. Empire thinking means, “Join me or I will kill you.” I believe in an ecosystem, where everyone is connected and helps one another.

Because Taobao became so large so quickly, I worried that we should leave room for the industry, competitors, and young people. In June, we split Taobao into four parts. People had told me, “Jack, after nine years you are so big that it is difficult to compete with you.” I said, “Then I will become smaller so you can compete.” If we are still too big ten years from now, I may split it again.

We must run a big company like a small company and give young people opportunities to lead. Taobao, Facebook, Google, and Tencent do not truly belong to China or the United States. They belong to this era, the twenty-first century. We need new ways of running such companies. I do not know the perfect method; we are testing and making mistakes. We believe in ecosystems, not empires.

As for competitors, I think perhaps they should change their model. I do not see anything wrong with Taobao’s model. We are growing, we can make money, and we can support more people. I do not like the model in which an internet company buys goods, holds inventory, and resells everything itself.

Last year, 2.1 billion packages were delivered in China, and Taobao generated nearly 1.1 billion of them. This year the number generated by Taobao may reach three billion. We do not want our own logistics system. China may eventually need ten million delivery workers. How could we run a company with ten million employees? We already had 23,000 people, which was headache enough.

We should support logistics companies so that they deliver well and serve customers well. We have capital, influence, and orders; the question is how to use them to improve society. We do not intend to own a logistics company.

Regarding Alipay, Jerry Yang and Masayoshi Son are good friends and partners. I understand why people asked how I could make that decision. We discussed the issue. Today the problem has been resolved, and they are satisfied. I now carry a heavy burden because Alipay is growing quickly but still does not have a mature profit model, while it may eventually owe a large payment to Alibaba Group.

That is a challenge for our young people: create a good model. The discussions among Jerry, Masa, and us were healthy. Unfortunately, a rumor spread that I had transferred the company without a board meeting or notice. The truth is that they knew, and we discussed it together.

If Alipay died, Taobao could be endangered, and eight million Taobao sellers could be in trouble. I could not allow that. Nor could I ignore Chinese law; otherwise, I would be invited to “drink coffee” with regulators in Beijing every week. As a company becomes larger, it must be transparent. In the twenty-first century, everything should be transparent. That was the reality we had to face.

Questioner 5: Thank you for the speech. What is Taobao’s view of international technology collaboration? I understand that its API is still not open to countries outside China, so companies there cannot build products on the Taobao platform. Do you plan to change that?

Jack Ma: We would love to open the API outside China. The main difficulty is payment. When I travel, many overseas Chinese tell me Taobao is wonderful and ask whether they can buy and sell from abroad. We are working on it, and if the payment problem is solved, things can move much faster.

Taobao will not remain only in China. It comes from China, but it belongs to the world and to this generation. We want it to help more people in the future, because there are many remarkable things on Taobao.

Questioner 6: You have said that there should be no difficult business in the world. But many foreign companies find it very difficult to do business in China. They have trouble learning about the services Alibaba Group can provide and navigating policy and government issues. Do you plan to help foreign companies enter China, where consumers still want foreign products?

Jack Ma: Doing business is difficult everywhere. Foreign companies encounter problems in China, and Chinese companies encounter major problems in the United States. I do not see many truly successful Chinese companies in America or Europe yet. Someone mentioned Alibaba; not yet. Someone mentioned Lenovo; do you call that fully successful?

By contrast, some foreign companies have succeeded in China. Microsoft, IBM, Oracle, and many others have done reasonably well. Business anywhere takes time. No market welcomes gamblers. If you enter a market, create value for local people, and give it time, you will have a chance.

My wife and I debated this while driving yesterday. She thought small businesses might find America difficult because everything seemed to be a chain—large retailers, restaurants, even coffee shops. I thought America made it easier for small businesses. A professor beside us said we should hold a debate about whether the United States or China is easier for business.

If you still think business in China depends on following officials or cultivating guanxi, forget it. For twelve years I have repeatedly said that if someone tells you, “I have a strong relationship with the mayor,” you should forget that person. The only relationship that truly matters is the relationship with the customer. If customers love you, the government will probably love you too, because it needs taxes and jobs.

My approach to government has always been: fall in love with it, but do not marry it. I respect officials, tell them the truth, and communicate with them, but I do not do business with government. That earns respect. In Alipay’s case, we had to listen because it was about law, not guanxi.

Do not stand far away saying, “My God, that place is difficult.” Go there and test it. Jump in. You never learn to swim until you enter the water. China is not that bad. People ask why China has no Apple. The United States has had capitalism for more than two hundred years; generations of companies have grown and died, enriching the soil. China had only thirty years of reform and opening by then, and its companies were not doing badly.

Wait another thirty years and China will have great companies too. They will not belong only to China; in the internet age, they will belong to the world. They will belong to young people born in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s—including many of the students here. They are the future.

Questioner 7: I used to work at eBay and PayPal, so I understand some of your challenges. Around 2000, before the Sydney Olympics, I remember seeing an Alibaba television advertisement in Australia. Alibaba was only about two years old, yet you already had global ambitions. Twelve years later, the company is much stronger. What is your future globalization strategy?

Jack Ma: When we first had money, we started making mistakes. We moved into a beautiful office, hired MBAs and vice presidents from multinational companies, and after having money for only five minutes we began thinking about globalization. Jesus!

In 2002, we decided to return to basics and return to China. We joked that B2C meant “back to China,” “back to basics,” and “back to the coast.” We told ourselves: global vision, local win. However wonderful your vision is, your feet must stay on the ground and you must do the hard work every day.

Twelve years later, we still believe in global vision and local winning. We have tested ideas in Japan, India, Europe, and elsewhere, and we never closed our U.S. office. I am now taking one year away because I want to learn.

CEOs of Fortune 500 companies all say China is a large and interesting market, but few put everything aside and spend a year there. If you really want to understand China, you must spend time there. In the same way, I believe the United States and Europe can become important markets for us, so I am putting things down and spending a year here.

I want to understand how we can help American small businesses, how we differ from Amazon and eBay, and what real value we can create. Once we understand that clearly, we can begin. We should never try to finish a twenty-year plan in two years. Life is short, but it is also long. We have time, and we will move step by step.

We will not begin by asking how much revenue we can take out of China. We will ask what value we can bring to local people. More than 15 million small businesses outside China were already using our services, and we did not charge them. Free is often the best. We will keep working on it. Thank you.

Questioner 8: I welcomed you to the United States and said I hoped you could rest well here. What is the biggest misunderstanding America has about China, and what is the biggest misunderstanding China has about America?

Jack Ma: Honestly, I do not know. There are many misunderstandings. People believe they know China inside and out, but nobody completely knows China. Others claim to know the United States inside and out, but they do not. Even presidents do not fully know such a vast country. It is difficult to know everything outside yourself, but you can know yourself.

What do you need? What do you want? What are you willing to give up? If I know myself better, I can change myself to work with the outside world. There will always be misunderstandings between China and the United States, just as there are misunderstandings among people from different parts of China. Our job is not to eliminate every misunderstanding; our job is to improve ourselves and adapt to others.

I came here because I saw Americans pointing fingers at China without ever having been there, and Chinese people criticizing the United States without ever having visited. We need to learn to appreciate one another. The more time I spend in the United States, the more I love it. Communication matters. Politics is difficult, but there is one thing I am happy to do: business.

I do not like online games. I believe the best game in the world is making money by helping small businesses cross the ocean, trade, and understand one another. My grandfather learned the news from newspapers. My father learned it from radio. Our generation learned about the world from television. Our children learn through the internet, and they say, “I want to participate.”

The internet has transformed this era. When something happens in the United States, people in China know immediately. When something happens in China, you learn most of it very quickly. Let us appreciate that. Doing things step by step is more important than trying to get everything overnight. Thank you.

Questioner 9: You said that many Silicon Valley venture capitalists rejected you, but one investor here played a major role in Alibaba’s success: Jerry Yang. Yahoo invested about one billion dollars in Alibaba in 2005. Could you discuss your relationship with Jerry, how the investment happened, and how important it was to Alibaba’s growth?

Jack Ma: Jerry is a very good personal friend and a lifelong friend. Our families are also close. But business is business. Yahoo invested in us in 2005, and I think both sides benefited. Without Yahoo’s investment, we would not be as successful as we are today.

We did not need the cash simply to solve an operating problem. We needed it to solve a venture-capital problem: some early investors did not believe Alibaba had a future and wanted to cash out. The Yahoo deal also taught us how to partner with a big company, what problems big companies face, and how to improve our own culture.

But if today’s situation never changes, we will not have a bright future; we have to do something. Fairly speaking, we appreciate yesterday while looking for a better tomorrow. Every company should do that. Jerry and I remain close. We talk, chat, and play golf. We like Yahoo. It was one of the companies that awakened me to the internet, and I will appreciate that all my life. Without the internet, there would be no Jack Ma and no Alibaba.

Moderator: We have time for one final question.

Questioner 10: You said you are interested in buying Yahoo. First, have you visited Yahoo during this trip? Second, how are you going to buy it?

Jack Ma: The honest answer to the first question is no. I have been here for fifteen days, mostly sleeping and reading. I have not had time, and sleep is more important now because there is a long and difficult road ahead.

Questioner 10: And how would you buy Yahoo?

Jack Ma: We are interested in the whole company—the whole of Yahoo. Yahoo China is already ours; it is already in my pocket.

Questioner 10: Thank you. Amid all the confusion, that is the first crystal-clear answer about Yahoo I have heard. As a reporter, I appreciate it. So when will it happen?

Jack Ma: Honestly, I do not know. It is more complicated than we thought. Many people are interested. We are talking to them, and they are talking to us. I am told the difficulties are not only about money; they also involve politics and internal issues. I can only cross my fingers and say that we are very, very interested. Thank you.

entrepreneurshipstanford universityJack MaAlibabasmall businesses

About the Speaker

View details→
马云 (Jack Ma)

马云 (Jack Ma)

Founder of Alibaba Group

Birth:1964Country:China

Jack Ma, born Ma Yun in Hangzhou, Zhejiang, in 1964, is a Chinese entrepreneur and the founder of Alibaba Group. After graduating from university, he worked as an English teacher before founding Alibaba with a team in Hangzhou in 1999. The company helped expand business-to-business e-commerce, online retail, digital payments, and cloud computing in China. Ma served as Alibaba's chief executive and later as executive chairman, stepping down as chairman in 2019. He has frequently spoken about entrepreneurship, education, the digital economy, inclusive finance, and globalization, while supporting philanthropic and rural-education initiatives. He also served as co-chair of the United Nations High-level Panel on Digital Cooperation and as an advocate for the UN Sustainable Development Goals. His forceful public views on technology, finance, regulation, and business transformation have attracted broad influence as well as controversy.

「Today is cruel, tomorrow is crueler, and the day after tomorrow is beautiful. But the vast majority of people die on tomorrow night, unable to see the sun of the day after tomorrow.」

Related Speeches

Tel Aviv University Honorary Doctorate Acceptance Speech
2018-05-03·Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel

Tel Aviv University Honorary Doctorate Acceptance Speech

On May 3, 2018, Tel Aviv University awarded Jack Ma an honorary doctorate, and he delivered a speech on behalf of all honorary degree recipients. Ma admitted he was not a good student by traditional standards — he failed the university entrance exam twice — and urged everyone to never give up and not be disappointed in themselves: if you cannot get into a good university or find a job, do not despair, for in 20 years you may join a better university or start a company like Alibaba. He praised Israel for becoming a miracle in 70 years through wisdom, innovation, and persistence despite lacking natural resources such as diamonds, oil, and water, emphasizing that the human brain is the world's most precious asset and that tough experiences make people different — the Jewish people's focus on education and the brain rather than wealth explains why they win 22% of Nobel Prizes. Ma explained Alibaba's mission to help small businesses, believing small is beautiful and small is powerful, and that beauty means peace, green, and inclusiveness. He mentioned learning the word 「Chutzpah」 in Israel — the courage to challenge convention, a spirit of the 21st century and the tech revolution. He further argued that the shift from IT to DT is a change of mindset rather than technology; in the future machines will be like people but will never have love, success requires IQ and EQ, while being respected requires LQ (the quotient of love); the future economy should be about sharing, transparency, and responsibility. Finally, he urged that the third technological revolution should not bring wars, and if there is to be war, humanity should unite against poverty, disease, and environmental pollution — the annual death toll from cancer equals that of WWI, and deaths from poverty, disease, and pollution exceed those of WWII.

← Back to Speeches